Ekonomia Online
LATEST

Suspicions of a murder disguised as a traffic accident; detective calls for case to be reopened

Detective Fatmir Bardhoci has raised serious suspicions about how Kosovo’s justice institutions handled the case of the death of a person who was a U.S. citizen of Kosovo origin, reports Ekonomia Online.

He claims that his death may be linked to two other criminal incidents, including the death of a woman, and is calling for the case to be reopened and handled by the Serious Crimes Prosecution Office.

Bardhoci, who has said he was authorized by the U.S. Congress to investigate the case, said the investigation was initiated following a request from the victim’s family, specifically his brother, Haki Dervishaj, with the aim of establishing the circumstances of the death.

He stated that during the investigation, suspicions were identified regarding the involvement of certain individuals and institutional structures in the failure to solve the case.

“Following an investigation conducted with us as representatives of the U.S. Congress as well, because the person in question is a U.S. citizen, and following requests made by his family, the victim’s brother, Haki Dervishi, initiated this international investigation to establish the causes of his brother’s death,” Bardhoci stated.

He said this is a serious case which, according to his claims and the evidence he says was obtained during the investigation, may also be connected to another criminal incident.

“We conducted an investigation, also supported by various structures, to establish the facts of this incident, and I want to stress that it is a macabre and very serious incident. Not only because it involves a U.S. citizen, but according to the investigation and suspicions based on evidence, it has emerged that this incident may be connected to another criminal incident involving the hanging of a woman,” he said.

According to Bardhoci, this possible connection makes the case even more serious, while he has raised concerns about the handling of cases of violence against women and how institutions have acted in such cases.

One of the detective’s main claims concerns how the death of Hysni Dervishaj was handled by Kosovo’s institutions. According to him, the case was classified as a traffic accident, although he claims to have evidence raising suspicions of murder.

Bardhoci has claimed that some police and prosecution structures may have obstructed the full resolution of the case.

“But what is most important is the involvement of certain police or prosecution structures in failing to solve this incident and obstructing justice, making it possible for the direction of the investigation into this incident to be changed as well, reclassifying it from murder as a road accident,” Bardhoci stated.

He added that, according to the documentation and evidence he claims to have obtained, there is suspicion that the incident was deliberately treated as a traffic accident so that the potentially responsible individuals would not be investigated.

“According to the evidence we have found and which is based on facts, there is reasonable suspicion that the criminal incident was deliberately steered in such a way that it would not be solved and would be treated as a traffic accident. This makes it possible to eliminate every subject under investigation, with the aim of closing the case and concealing this criminal incident,” he said.

Bardhoci stated that he had held discussions with senior officials in the Kosovo Police and the Prosecution Office in Gjakova, but claims that his investigation identified possible links between certain individuals and the incident.

“We spoke with some senior officials in the Kosovo Police and the Gjakova Prosecution Office to solve this incident. I want to say that, according to all the investigations, it is indicated and established that this incident was also linked to police structures, and to individuals whom we suspect are connected to the incident and may have committed the murder. According to our suspicions, these individuals are also connected to the murder or hanging of a woman, a case that has never been solved, but was covered up and classified as a suicide,” Bardhoci stated.

He also called for the case to receive the attention of institutions and the media, stressing that failure to solve such cases may have further consequences for society.

“The family’s lawyer and the victim’s brother, Hysni Dervishaj, are here with me. I think greater media presence is needed to intensify the process we have begun to solve this incident. As I have also requested of Kosovo’s justice authorities, we are calling for this incident to be reopened. Kosovo’s State Prosecutor’s Office must resume the criminal investigation and not leave this case classified as a traffic accident, but have it handled by the Serious Crimes Prosecution Office, because we are not dealing with an incident involving only one person; according to our suspicions, there are three criminal incidents directly connected to one another,” he said.

The family’s lawyer, Fehmie Gashi Bytyqi, has also raised concerns about how the case of Hysni Dervishaj was handled, saying that despite her repeated requests to the prosecution, a number of investigative actions were either not undertaken or yielded no results.

She said the case dates back to 2022 and that the proceedings have remained suspended because the incident was treated as a traffic accident.

“Despite the fact that every letter I have sent is in the case file and that I have repeatedly addressed the prosecutor handling the case, who inherited it, we are talking about an incident that occurred in 2022. In other words, we are discussing an incident that happened four years ago,” Gashi Bytyqi stated.

According to her, she has also repeatedly contacted the chief prosecutor, requesting that the family’s concerns be addressed, but the institutions’ response has been that the case was suspended because it was considered a traffic accident.

The lawyer said that in recent months two people have also been included in the investigation; according to the prosecution, security cameras identified them driving cars in the relevant area.

“Their explanation was that the case had been suspended because it was considered a traffic accident. Until a few months ago, two people had been included; according to the prosecution, cameras at homes captured them driving. Samples were taken from those cars and sent to the Kosovo Forensic Agency, but nothing was established from those samples. They also tried to send them to America, but the sample was damaged here at the Kosovo Forensic Agency, as happens in other cases too,” she said.

According to the lawyer, some of the remaining material was later sent to Switzerland for examination, but the Swiss authorities also requested a larger amount of material before providing a definitive answer.

“The remaining part of the sample, which is far too small to establish whether those two cars, whose owners are suspects, ran over this person, is now in Switzerland. The Swiss authorities said they cannot provide an answer with such a small amount. So the case has remained suspended,” Gashi Bytyqi stated.

One of the elements that, according to the lawyer, raised suspicions for Hysni Dervishaj’s family was the condition of the bicycle he was allegedly riding at the time of the incident.

She said the victim’s brother, Haki Dervishaj, who lived in the United States, returned to Kosovo after his brother’s death and immediately sought clarification about the circumstances of the incident.

According to her, the prosecution documents state that Hysni Dervishaj was riding a bicycle, but the family noticed that the bicycle had no damage whatsoever.

“One of the main clues was the fact that Haki, after his brother had been buried, came to Kosovo. He lived in America, but returned here, as he is a citizen of Kosovo and Gjakova. The first thing he did when he got home was, naturally, ask what vehicle his brother had been using. The prosecution documents say he was on a bicycle. But what is extremely concerning and suspicious is that the bicycle was absolutely undamaged and untouched,” the lawyer stated.

She added that the family had reason to seek clarification because, in her view, the circumstances of the death and the victim’s physical condition were inconsistent with an ordinary traffic accident.

“Haki was right to raise this concern. He firmly believed that an accident had been staged, because how is it possible for a person to lose their life under these circumstances when the bicycle was not damaged? From the photographs I have seen, the late Hysni Dervishaj had a very well-built physique. He also appeared to be in good physical condition and had no known health problems. His cousins also told me that he did not suffer from any illness,” Gashi Bytyqi said.

According to her, the condition of the bicycle was precisely one of the main reasons the family called for a more thorough investigation.

The lawyer also raised questions about how the police handled the bicycle and why it was not seized as material evidence.

“Another clue, which is extremely important in criminalistics, is that after Haki raised the concern about how it was possible for the bicycle to be returned, it is unknown where it was returned, who took it, and who received it. It was found at the scene, while the case documents state that, at the prosecution’s request, it was not seized, on the grounds that it was undamaged and there was no need. That is the explanation I read a few days ago,” she stated.

According to Gashi Bytyqi, after some time the bicycle disappeared, even though its condition was one of the family’s main concerns.

“Nevertheless, after some time, it is extremely mysterious that the bicycle—the one Haki raised concerns about in connection with his brother’s death—was stolen. In other words, it was removed; it disappeared. Despite the fact that Haki had hired another lawyer before me, the issue of the bicycle was never mentioned in his statements. I have insisted repeatedly and have also raised this matter officially,” the lawyer said.

She also criticized the amount of time the prosecution, in her view, took to seek clarification from police officers about the bicycle.

“Imagine, it took the prosecution almost three years to seek clarification from a Kosovo Police officer about that bicycle. I have requested answers about other matters and still have not received any answers to this day. In my 20 years of experience, it is extremely important that the police carry out these actions, rather than the lawyer having to request them. When we are dealing with an injured family that may not have the financial means to hire a lawyer, the institutions themselves should undertake these actions,” Gashi Bytyqi stated.

Another matter that the lawyer says she formally raised as part of the investigation is an examination of the victim’s phone, specifically his communications during the 24 hours before his death.

According to her, this action could have helped determine whether Hysni Dervishaj had communicated with other people before the incident and whether there was any information that could help establish the circumstances.

“I also have the letter I sent to the institutions, in which I requested at least an examination of the late Hysni Dervishaj’s phone for the 24 hours before his death. To check whether he communicated with anyone, whom he communicated with, and whether there was any contact that could help solve the case. But this request was not carried out,” the lawyer stated.

Through their representatives, Hysni Dervishaj’s family is asking the justice institutions to review how the case was handled, assess the evidence, and undertake the investigative actions that, according to them, have not been carried out.

The claims made by the detective and the lawyer, including suspicions of murder, obstruction of justice, and links to other criminal cases, remain their allegations and require verification by the competent authorities.

Related