Ekonomia Online
LATEST

Apple hit with $5.7 billion – loses lawsuit over vibration technology in iPhone and Apple Watch

Apple hit with $5.7 billion – loses lawsuit over vibration technology in iPhone and Apple Watch

Apple has faced one of the biggest legal blows in the company’s history, after a federal jury in California ordered it to pay around $5.72 billion for infringing two patents related to haptic technology, which enables vibrations in devices such as the iPhone and Apple Watch. The case was brought by […]

Apple has faced one of the biggest legal blows in the company’s history, after a federal jury in California ordered it to pay around $5.72 billion for infringing two patents related to haptic technology, which enables vibrations in devices such as the iPhone and Apple Watch.

The case was brought by Taction Technology, a company that makes headphones and audio devices. It sued Apple in 2021, claiming that the Taptic Engine system used technology protected by its two patents without authorization.

Haptic technology enables devices to create the sensation of touch through vibrations. On an iPhone, for example, a user can feel a physical response when touching a virtual button, while the Apple Watch uses vibrations for notifications, directions and other functions.

Apple first introduced the Taptic Engine in the Apple Watch in 2014 and later expanded the use of the technology to other products, Telegrafi reports.

Taction claimed that Apple’s improvements to its haptic system infringed two patents issued in 2020 and that the company was commercially benefiting from its technology without a license.

The case took another turn in 2023, when a federal judge in California ruled in Apple’s favor and concluded that the company had not infringed the patents. Taction appealed the decision, and the case returned to litigation, leading to the latest federal trial.

The jury has now concluded that Apple infringed claims in the two patents and awarded $5,721,961,750 in damages. However, the jury did not find that the infringement was willful, an element that matters in determining whether damages can be increased further under U.S. patent law.

Apple has strongly contested the decision and announced that it will appeal.

The company argues that the Taptic Engine is technologically different from Taction’s technology and claims that Apple’s own product tests conducted during the trial supported this position.

This means that the $5.72 billion sum is not necessarily the final payment. Apple may seek to change or overturn parts of the decision and then take the case to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which hears most appeals in patent cases.

The ruling marks another chapter in a series of legal battles over the technologies used in Apple’s devices.

In November 2025, a court also ordered Apple to pay $634 million to medical technology company Masimo, after a jury found it liable for infringing a patent related to blood oxygen measurement technology. /Telegrafi/

Related