Ekonomia Online
LATEST

Why do two people remember the same event completely differently: Is one of them lying?

Why do two people remember the same event completely differently: Is one of them lying?

One conversation, two completely opposite accounts and unwavering conviction on both sides. Psychology reveals a mechanism in the brain that could change everything we believe about the past.

Two people attend the same family gathering. During the conversation, one says something that the other experiences as an insult. A few days later, when they try to clear things up, they realize that their memories differ in almost every detail.

One insists that they were humiliated in front of everyone, while the other is convinced they only made an innocent joke.

Who is right? And does this mean that one of them is lying?

The answer is not so simple. Psychology shows that human memory is much more complicated than we think.

The brain is not a camera that records everything

We often believe that memories are accurate recordings of events. In reality, every time we recall something, the brain reconstructs the experience using stored information.

A study published in the scientific journal Memory Studies showed that accounts of personal events can change even within a week.

Participants described four events from their lives, imagining that they were telling them to a police officer, a psychologist or a friend. When they recounted them again seven days later, some details were missing, others had been added, and contradictions occasionally appeared.

This shows that changes in an account are not necessarily evidence of deliberate lying.

Even the way a question is asked can change a memory

One of the best-known experiments on memory was conducted in 1974 by psychologists Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer.

Participants watched footage of car accidents and were then asked questions about the vehicles' speed.

The results showed that the wording of the question affected the answers. When a word suggesting a more forceful collision was used, participants estimated a higher speed.

A week later, some of them said they had seen broken glass, even though there was none in the footage.

The original study showed that later information can influence what we believe we remember.

Therefore, complete confidence in a memory does not necessarily guarantee its accuracy.

Why does each person remember different details?

A 2023 study published in Applied Cognitive Psychology followed 213 participants over 18 months, analyzing different aspects of memory for the same public event.

The researchers found that the ability to accurately remember one category of information does not necessarily mean the same level of accuracy in other categories.

Someone may remember the facts well, but not the emotions they experienced. Another person may remember the atmosphere while forgetting concrete details.

This helps us understand why two people can give different accounts without necessarily being dishonest.

When our beliefs influence what we see

Another psychological mechanism is confirmation bias, the tendency to give greater importance to information that supports our beliefs.

If we believe that someone does not respect us, we may interpret even ordinary comments as disrespectful.

If we trust that person, the same words may seem like a friendly joke.

The problem begins when we consider our personal interpretation to be the only possible explanation.

Then the conversation is no longer about understanding what happened, but about proving who is right.

Understanding the other person does not mean agreeing with them

In family relationships, friendships and couples, two things are often confused: the intention and the impact of an action.

One person may not have intended to hurt anyone, while the other may have genuinely felt hurt.

Acknowledging someone's feelings does not necessarily require agreeing with their interpretation.

For example, we can say:

“I understand that my words hurt you, although that was not my intention.”

However, it is important to note that not every version of an event is equally accurate. Facts can be verified, and responsibility for harmful behavior does not disappear simply because someone remembers the situation differently.

When the desire to win the argument harms the relationship

Sometimes, years of unspoken resentment lie behind a small argument.

One person may experience disagreement as rejection, while the other may fear that admitting a mistake will make them seem weak.

In this way, a sentence uttered during a family dinner can turn into an argument about everything that has gone unresolved for years.

Emotional maturity does not mean always giving up your point of view, but being willing to examine it and listen to the other person.

Because, in the end, the problem is not always that two people see the same event differently, but that one of them believes that only their perspective can be valid. /Telegrafi/

Related