We like to think that we are rational creatures. We pay attention to what we do, weigh the pros and cons, take an umbrella when we think it might rain. But both neuroscience and the social sciences tell us that we are more optimistic than realistic. In general, we expect things to go better than they do. […]
The power of optimism is scientifically proven

We like to think that we are rational creatures. We pay attention to what we do, weigh the pros and cons, take an umbrella when we think it might rain. But both neuroscience and the social sciences tell us that we are more optimistic than realistic.
In general, we expect things to go better than they do. We usually underestimate the likelihood that we will get divorced, lose our jobs, or have a tumor. We expect our children to be very talented, imagine being more successful than our peers, and think we will live longer.
Psychologists call it “optimism bias”: the belief that the future will be much better than the past and the present. This phenomenon is found in all societies and across all economic and social groups. When imagining what they will do when they grow up, children are very optimistic, but adults are no less so. A 2005 study found that people over 60 are just as likely as younger people to see the glass as half full.
One might expect optimism to fade in the face of a flood of news about wars, unemployment, cyclones, and all the other catastrophes that threaten human life. In practice, we can become pessimistic on a collective level: about the direction our country is taking or politicians’ ability to improve education and reduce crime. But private optimism, the kind that has to do with our personal future, is very resilient. A survey conducted in 2007 demonstrates this: although 70% of respondents thought marriages lasted less than they did in our parents’ time, 76% were optimistic about the future of their own families.
Excessive optimism can lead us to make big mistakes, skip regular medical checkups, fail to use sunscreen, not save money, or even lose our homes because of a bad investment. But this bias also protects us, helping us move forward instead of jumping out of a window. Without optimism, our ancestors would never have left their tribes, and perhaps we would still be living in caves, dreaming of the light.
To make progress, we need to be able to imagine different, better realities and believe that we can create them. This belief drives us to pursue our goals. Optimists usually tend to work and earn more. Economists at Duke University have found that optimists even save more. And although they are just as likely to get divorced, they are more likely to remarry, a fact that, as Samuel Johnson said, marks the triumph of hope over experience. Even though that better future is often an illusion, optimism offers clear advantages in the present. Hope keeps intelligence alive, reduces stress, and improves physical health.
A study of heart disease found that optimistic people are more likely to follow a diet high in vitamins and low in fat, as well as to exercise, thereby reducing their risk. Meanwhile, a study of cancer patients found that pessimistic patients under 60 are more likely to die within 8 months than their non-pessimistic peers in the same circumstances. In fact, recent scientific studies show that optimism may be a product of evolution. The science of optimism, once dismissed and considered intellectually unreliable, is opening up a new perspective on how the human mind works. And it could bring about a revolution in psychology, demonstrating that our brain is conditioned not only by the past, but is also continually shaped by our vision of the future.
I would like to say that my study of optimism sprang from a deep interest in the positive side of human nature, but the truth is that I discovered the optimism innate in our brains entirely by chance. After the September 11 attacks in New York, I had decided to conduct a study on people’s memories of that day. One fact had struck me: many of them were convinced that their memories were extremely accurate, like a film imprinted on their minds, when in fact they were often full of errors. A nationwide survey showed that after 11 months, people’s memories of that experience matched only 63% of the accounts they had given immediately after the attack. Respondents also had difficulty remembering details, such as the names of the airlines. Where did these errors come from?
Memory researchers proposed a striking answer: perhaps memories are sometimes inaccurate in part because the neural system that enables us to remember past episodes did not evolve precisely for that purpose. In fact, the primary function of memory may be to imagine the future, in order to prepare us for what will happen. According to scientists, the system did not arise to bring past events back to us perfectly, but to construct scenarios of the future in our minds. As a result, memory ends up being a process of reconstruction, and sometimes it inserts some details and eliminates others.
To verify this, I decided to record the brain activity of some volunteers while they imagined future events from their everyday lives, and to compare the findings with the patterns I had observed when those same people recalled past events. But something strange happened. When the volunteers began imagining the future, even the most ordinary episodes of everyday life took an optimistic turn. Scenes that would normally have been banal were illuminated by positive details, as if everything had been written by a talented Hollywood screenwriter. Do you think there is nothing exciting about imagining getting your hair cut?
Read how one of the interviewees imagined that moment: “I was getting my hair cut to donate it to Locks of Love (a charity that provides wigs to cancer patients). I had been growing it for years, and all my friends were there to celebrate with me. We went to my hairdresser in Brooklyn and then had lunch at our favorite restaurant.”
I asked another woman to imagine a plane trip: “I imagined taking off, my favorite moment, then sleeping for eight hours during the flight, and finally landing and applauding the pilot,” she replied. No waiting on the runway, no newborn crying. The world had become a wonderful place. What does it tell us about our brains that, when it came to their personal futures, all the interviewees tended to think positively? Does the tendency toward optimism depend on how the brain is structured? To think positively about what will happen to us, we first need to be able to imagine ourselves in the future. Optimism begins with what is perhaps the most extraordinary human ability: the ability to travel with our minds, to go forward and backward through time and space.
Although many of us take it for granted, this ability to imagine a different space and time is actually essential to our survival. It allows us to plan, store food and resources for times when we may not have them, and work toward a future reward. It also allows us to anticipate how our behavior today will affect future generations. If we could not imagine the world 100 years from now, would we worry about global warming? Would we make an effort to live healthily? Would we have children?
Antidote to despair
If the ability to travel through time with our minds has survival advantages, the ability to consciously predict the future comes at a very high price, because it means becoming aware that one day we will die. Ajit Varki, a biologist at the University of California, San Diego, says that awareness of our mortality has led evolution into a dead end. Despair interfered with our daily affairs, preventing us from carrying out the activities necessary for survival. The only way this ability to mentally travel through time could emerge during evolution was in the form of irrational optimism. Awareness of death had to be accompanied by a tendency to imagine a bright future.
The ability to imagine the future arises in part in the hippocampus, a brain region fundamental to memory. People who have suffered damage to the hippocampus cannot remember the past, but they also cannot construct detailed images of the future. They seem frozen in time. We all constantly move back and forth through time. We can remember a conversation we had with our spouse yesterday and immediately afterward decide where to go for dinner tonight. But the brain does not travel randomly through time. It tends to dwell on certain thoughts. We think about what our children will do in life, or how to get the job we like, how to buy a house in the countryside, or find an ideal partner.
We imagine our team winning a decisive match, eagerly look forward to a pleasant evening out, or fantasize about winning the lottery. We also worry about losing the people we love, making mistakes at work, or dying in a terrible plane crash, but studies show that most of us spend less time dwelling on negative things than on positive ones. When we imagine a loss or a heart attack, we tend to focus on how to avoid them.
A study I conducted several years ago with neuroscientist Elisabeth Phelps found that our tendency to think positively arises from communication between the frontal cortex and deeper subcortical regions of our brain. The frontal cortex is the part of the brain that has evolved most recently. In humans, it is larger than in other mammals and is essential for functions such as language and the ability to set goals.
Using magnetic resonance imaging, we recorded the brain activity of a group of volunteers while they imagined specific future events that might happen to them. Some events were desirable, others undesirable. Everyone said that the images of positive events were more detailed. This corresponded with the greater activity we had observed in two critical brain regions: the amygdala, a small structure deep in the brain that is fundamental to processing emotions, and the rACC, an area of the frontal cortex that modulates emotions and motivations. The rACC regulates traffic, facilitating the flow of positive emotions and associations.
The more optimistic a person was, the more intense the activity in these regions while they imagined positive future events, and the greater the communication between the two structures.
Negative outcomes
The problem with pessimistic expectations, such as those of clinically depressed people, is that they have the power to change the future, thereby predetermining negative outcomes. In what sense do expectations change reality? To answer this question, my colleague, neuroscientist Sara Bengtsson, devised an experiment in which she manipulated the positive and negative expectations of a group of students before testing them on cognitive tasks and observing their brains with magnetic resonance imaging. To give them expectations of success, she told the students before the test that they were intelligent and capable. To have the opposite effect, she told them they were stupid and ignorant. She found that the students who received a positive message performed better.
It also turned out that the students’ brains responded differently to the mistakes they made. When a mistake followed encouraging words, there was greater brain activity. When the students had heard that they were stupid, there was no increase in activity recorded after a wrong answer. It seemed as if their brains expected them to do badly and showed no sign of surprise when they made a mistake. A brain that does not expect good results does not receive the signal: “Careful, wrong answer!” So it does not learn from its mistakes and usually does not improve over time.
Expectations become self-fulfilling by changing performance and behavior, which ultimately affects what will happen in the future. But often expectations simply change the way we perceive the world without changing reality itself. Here’s an example. As I’m writing, a friend calls me. He is at Heathrow Airport, waiting to board a plane to Austria, where he is going skiing. The plane is 3 hours late because of a snowstorm at the destination. “I imagine it’s both a good thing and a bad thing,” he tells me. Waiting at the airport is unpleasant, but if it snows today, the skiing will be better tomorrow. His brain is working to reconcile the annoyance of the delay with the desire for a lovely vacation.
A canceled trip is not a tragedy, but even when something terrible happens to us that we never expected, we automatically seek confirmation that our misfortune is actually a blessing. We did not expect to lose our jobs, get sick, or get divorced, but when it happens, we look for the bright side. We think these experiences help us grow. Perhaps in the future we will find a better job or a more stable relationship. Interpreting misfortune in this way allows us to conclude that our optimistic expectations were ultimately correct: things turned out well.
How can we find the bright side of a misfortune?
To answer this question, two colleagues, Ray Dolan and Tamara Shiner, and I took some volunteers and scanned their brains while asking them to imagine a series of health problems, from a simple fracture to Alzheimer’s, and to rate how serious they considered them. Then we asked them which they would choose if they could: would they rather break a leg or an arm? Have gastritis or asthma? Finally, they had to rank the illnesses again. A few minutes after choosing one, the volunteers found that their choice frightened them less. For example, before choosing among the options, they considered a broken leg terrible. But after choosing it, they found a positive aspect and said: “If I broke one of my legs, I’d stay in bed and watch TV without feeling guilty.” The study also found that people perceived certain negative events positively if they had already experienced them.
It seems that our brains possess the philosopher’s stone, which allows us to turn lead into gold and maintain a normal level of well-being. It is programmed to place maximum value on the things that happen to us, and to give us confidence in the things we decide. This applies not only when we are forced to choose between two negative options, but also when we have to choose between two equally attractive job offers. Making a decision can be difficult and exhausting, but once we make it, a miracle happens.
All of a sudden, we judge the offer we chose to be better than we considered it before choosing it, and conclude that, after all, the other one wasn’t anything special. According to social psychologist Leon Festinger, after making a choice we reevaluate all the options to reduce the tension created by the difficulty of choosing between equally desirable things.
In another study conducted in 2009 with Ryan Dolan and Benedetto De Martino, again using a scanner, we asked some volunteers to imagine going on vacation to 80 different places and to think about how happy they would be in each one. Then we asked them to choose a destination between two they had rated equally: Paris or Brazil? Finally, we asked them to rate all of them again. Those surveyed placed greater value on the choices they had made earlier.
It is true that sometimes we regret or are disappointed by the choices we make. But overall, we value them more and expect them to give us more pleasure. This confirmation of our decisions helps us get more satisfaction from choices that might actually have been neutral. Without this mechanism, our lives would be full of regrets. Did we do the right thing? Should we change our minds? We would remain stuck, overwhelmed by indecision and unable to move forward. But how is it possible that people keep seeing everything through rose-colored glasses when it is so easy to find discouraging information? Only recently have we managed to solve this mystery by observing people’s brains as they process positive and negative information about the future. And what we have discovered is surprising: when we learn something, neurons faithfully record information that encourages optimism but not information that gives rise to undesirable expectations. When we hear about a success story like Mark Zuckerberg’s, our brain takes note of the possibility that one day we too will become very rich. But if we discover that the chances of divorce are almost 50%, we do not think that our marriage is destined to fail.
The enigma
Why is the brain programmed this way? Our hypothesis is that optimism was selected by evolution precisely because, in general, positive expectations increase the chances of survival. Optimists live longer and are healthier, most human beings tend to be optimistic, and optimism is linked to specific genes: all this research seems to confirm our theory. But optimism can produce undesirable outcomes. At this point the problem is: how can we continue to hope, that is, to be optimistic, while also protecting ourselves from life’s pitfalls? I am convinced that one of the solutions is awareness. Understanding our biases is not innate. The brain’s illusions must be identified using scientific methods and then made known to everyone. Once we understand that optimism is an illusion, we will know how to protect ourselves.
The good news is that this awareness does not shatter our illusions at all. The glass remains half full, and we can find the right balance: that is, think we will not get sick, but at the same time pay for health insurance; be sure the sun will shine, but still take an umbrella before we go out. You never know.

















