Have you ever wondered, or asked your friends as you see them using some alternative tobacco products, how they differ from the conventional cigarettes we are used to seeing all the time? We believe the first answer has to do with the terminology; you may have heard terms such as smokeless tobacco, heated tobacco, or devices that […]
How does heated tobacco differ from e-cigarettes and conventional cigarettes?

Have you ever wondered, or asked your friends as you see them using some alternative tobacco products, how they differ from the conventional cigarettes we are used to seeing all the time? We believe the first answer has to do with the terminology; you may have heard terms such as smokeless tobacco, heated tobacco, or devices that heat tobacco sticks. These products essentially heat tobacco to create an aerosol that is inhaled by the user.
To address the curiosity surrounding smoke-free alternatives in recent times, the FDA, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, recently published a list of the differences between traditional cigarettes, heated tobacco, and e-cigarettes.
What is the difference between cigarettes, heated tobacco, and e-cigarettes?
A cigarette consists mainly of tobacco leaves wrapped in thin paper. It may also contain a filter, chemical additives, or other ingredients. The user lights the tip of the cigarette to burn the tobacco and inhales the smoke through the unlit end.
Smokeless tobacco consists of a heating source and the tobacco stick. The tobacco may be wrapped in paper, making it look similar to a cigarette. However, the tobacco is heated to a lower temperature than a burning cigarette to create an aerosol that the user inhales.
An e-cigarette uses a liquid that may contain nicotine (usually derived from the tobacco plant), glycerin, propylene glycol, flavorings, and other ingredients. The device has an electric heat source that warms the liquid to create an aerosol that the user inhales.
How does smokeless tobacco work?
There are two types of smokeless tobacco currently authorized for sale in the U.S. The first, which has been on the American market since the 1990s, uses a carbon tip wrapped in glass fibers. The user lights the carbon tip, which heats the dried tobacco inside to a temperature that does not cause the product to produce ash or burn completely.
The other smoke-free product, which recently received FDA authorization in April 2019, consists of an electronic heating device and tobacco sticks wrapped in paper. The user inserts the stick into the electronic heating device, which heats the tobacco using a ceramic blade, creating an aerosol.
What about other types of heated tobacco products?
There is a variety of products that may informally be known as heated tobacco products but do not readily fit into the categories of approved products. Products currently sold in global markets may work in different ways. For example, these products heat to different temperatures, may contain dry, moist, or liquid tobacco ingredients, and come in a variety of forms.
But the FDA clarifies that if a tobacco product meets the legal definition of a cigarette, and the tobacco is not heated to a high temperature that causes combustion, the product will currently be categorized as heated tobacco and legally regulated as a cigarette. The types of heated tobacco products currently authorized for sale in the U.S. are all part of the smokeless tobacco category.
Is smokeless tobacco safer than conventional cigarettes?
In its response, the FDA clarifies that there is no safe tobacco product. Smokeless tobacco may help reduce the risk of tobacco-related harm for adult smokers who switch completely from conventional cigarettes. It emphasizes that all tobacco products can lead to nicotine dependence.
(Photo: Sarah Johnson/ blacknote.com)

















