The head of the Kosovo Chamber of Commerce (KCC), Safet Gërxhaliu, has said that the announcement of wage increases in the public sector is a heavy blow to Kosovo, as it will deepen the poverty gap and be discriminatory in relation to the private sector. Indeed, today, October 17, as the International Day for the Eradication of Poverty is marked, Gërxhaliu […]
Gërxhaliu: Wage increases deepen the poverty gap

The head of the Kosovo Chamber of Commerce (KCC), Safet Gërxhaliu, has said that the announcement of wage increases in the public sector is a heavy blow to Kosovo, as it will deepen the poverty gap and be discriminatory in relation to the private sector.
Indeed, today, October 17, as the International Day for the Eradication of Poverty is marked, Gërxhaliu told “Epoka e Re” in an interview that Kosovo has high rates of extreme poverty and unemployment due to discriminatory policies in Kosovo.
Mr. Gërxhaliu, today is officially the International Day for the Eradication of Poverty. Where does Kosovo stand in this regard?
Gërxhaliu: It is more than true that in Kosovo there is much more talk about economic development and economic sustainability than is actually done, and as a consequence of such a situation, today we have extreme poverty, with more than 13% of the population living on less than 1 euro a day, and an unemployment rate that truly jeopardizes Kosovo’s social future, or, if I may call it that, “we have a ticking time bomb” for Kosovo’s future. All of this is happening at a time when the political agenda is dominating, so I fear that in Kosovo, there is much more talk about the economy than action. When we add to all this the fact that during the 2017 election campaigns there is much more talk about raising wages in the public sector and not about supporting the private sector, this is proof that this gap or discrepancy will continue in the future as well, and Kosovo will face negative trends that do no honor to its integration processes and aspirations for the future.
How do you comment on the announcement that wages in Kosovo will increase by 5% or more?
Gërxhaliu: We at the KCC have recommended that Kosovo’s economic future should be based on the rule of law and scientific expertise, all in the service of strengthening the private sector. There can be no economic and social sustainability if the private sector is not strengthened. The promises made to increase wages in the public sector are harmful to Kosovo, both internally and externally. Internally, such an approach demotivates the people of Kosovo from working in the private sector and aspiring to be employed in this sector. Given that there is no performance or accountability, all of this will put Kosovo in a very difficult situation, when perhaps tomorrow the private sector will face a shortage of labor. This will be a blow to foreign investors considering coming to Kosovo, since if an institutional policy supports only the public administration, it takes the country back to the past, not forward to the future. Therefore, the productive sector must be supported, and the balance of payments, which unfortunately remains negative, must be improved through it.
In your opinion, should there not be wage increases in the public sector?
Gërxhaliu: Definitely not, as wage increases in the public sector would be the biggest blow that could be dealt to Kosovo.
According to the latest report by the Central Bank of Kosovo, public debt has increased, along with spending on wages and per diems. How do you comment on this?
Gërxhaliu: We have supported having discipline with regard to domestic debt, since many economically developed countries have achieved positive growth through debt; however, that debt has financed projects that were justified and had positive feasibility. Unfortunately, in Kosovo borrowing is intended much more for spending on per diems, wages and institutional luxuries than for generating positive effects. All of this must be reviewed, and greater financial discipline must be exercised in the future if we are to avoid exceeding the debt limit set out in the projections of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. In other words, projects that generate positive effects for Kosovo’s future in the medium or long term must be financed. Care is needed in this regard, since relations with international financial institutions would be damaged, and Kosovo would suffer, because such debt must be in line with economic growth, and current trends in 2017 are not so positive that 4% economic growth will be achieved.
Mr. Gërxhaliu, based on the current political circumstances, what is the business climate like in Kosovo?
Gërxhaliu: Given the fact that the political agenda has dominated this entire year and continues to do so, and if we also analyze the local-level runoffs, then 2017 can be called “an economic failure.” Although positive steps have been taken in some areas, nevertheless, in a country where the political agenda dominates, it is difficult to talk about positive economic processes.
Economic diplomacy and economic attachés have been discussed for some time, and given their politicization, in your opinion, what is the state of economic diplomacy?
Gërxhaliu: If Kosovo’s diplomacy is analyzed, it is much more burdened by political issues, which is why economic diplomacy is weak. If you look at the countries of the region and beyond, they make economic diplomacy a priority. It should not surprise us that countries in the region are doing much better in this regard and, thanks to economic diplomacy, are increasing exports and foreign investment, improving their image and accelerating integration processes. In Kosovo, the opposite is truly the case, and it is time for economic diplomacy to be taken seriously. First and foremost, we need qualified people, transparency and the rule of law, as well as depoliticization, because politicization and economic diplomacy are two opposing worlds.
There have been many complaints from businesses about penalties imposed by the Tax Administration of Kosovo (TAK) when businesses are unable to pay their debts on time.?
Gërxhaliu: If we make a thorough analysis of penalty rates in comparison with countries in the region and beyond, Kosovo has the highest rate of penalties. We at the KCC have recommended that such penalties not be imposed and that the penalty rate be equal to the level of bank interest rates, or be eliminated, given that the rule of law is weak, businesses are not meeting their obligations, and the 2017 budget has not been reviewed. Thus, in the event of delays, businesses have the alternative of turning to banks and interest; therefore, penalties for businesses should be lower.
Mr. Gërxhaliu, in your opinion, what should be done about debt forgiveness?
Gërxhaliu: We at the Chamber of Commerce defend employers’ interests in this regard, and we have witnessed unfortunate situations occurring many times for the sake of individuals. The KCC supports any relief for the business community, because they are the heroes of postwar Kosovo: they create the budget, employ people, improve the balance of payments and promote the values of entrepreneurship. We oppose a selective approach, and everything should be on an equal footing and have positive effects for all sectors and the business community.
















