International law professor Muhamet Kelmendi has criticized the action of the Court of Appeal in Colmar, France, which postponed its decision on the release of Kosovo’s former prime minister, Ramush Haradinaj. In an interview with Epoka e Re, Kelmendi said that delaying the decision on the release of the AAK leader is […]
Kelmendi: The proceedings against Haradinaj are political

International law professor Muhamet Kelmendi has criticized the action of the Court of Appeal in Colmar, France, which postponed its decision on the release of Kosovo’s former prime minister, Ramush Haradinaj.
In an interview with Epoka e Re, Kelmendi said that delaying the decision on the release of the AAK leader was a political act with no legal basis. In this interview given to the newspaper “Epoka e Re,” Kelmendi said that the French state was acting on the basis of other interests in this case. “The Court of Colmar in France is acting on the basis of an accusation by Serbia that was not drafted in accordance with legal rules, whether those of the French state, international instruments, or the European Convention on Extradition. So, this court is not acting in accordance with these rules, but on the basis of other relations and other interests, which have more to do with the political sphere than the legal one,” Kelmendi said.
He stated that matters adjudicated by international courts cannot be the subject of proceedings in national courts. “Given that we are not dealing with a legal matter, because this action is not based either on the legal aspects of France’s domestic laws, under which the Court of Colmar must act, or on the European Convention on Extradition, it has nothing to do with justice. Responsibility for this case has already been established by an international court, of which France was also a member,” Kelmendi said. According to him, since the case has gone beyond legal boundaries, it is time for Kosovo’s institutions to respond on this front. “When we are not dealing with justice, the reason is political. Therefore, in this case, it is up to the Government of Kosovo to take a greater interest in this matter and take tougher measures toward the French state, because we are dealing with two sovereign and independent states that have recognized one another,” Kelmendi said, adding that the French ambassador in Pristina should be summoned and that, through him, France should be asked to respect the Republic of Kosovo.
The Court of Appeal in Colmar, France, has postponed its decision on AAK leader Ramush Haradinaj for three weeks. As a law professor, how would you assess this action by the French justice system?
Kelmendi: I think the Court of Colmar in France is acting on the basis of an accusation by Serbia that was not drafted in accordance with legal rules, whether those of the French state, international instruments, or the European Convention on Extradition. So, this court is not acting in accordance with these rules, but on the basis of other relations and other interests, which have more to do with the political sphere than the legal one. From a legal standpoint as well, we are dealing with an accusation that was examined by the International Court in The Hague, while, on the other hand, we are dealing with French domestic law, under which France itself has recognized Kosovo as an independent and sovereign state. France knows that the liberation war and NATO intervention were necessary to bring things to this point. So, under both French domestic law and Kosovo’s laws, this is a decision without legal weight, but with political weight. Completely different decisions are needed here.
Why do you think France is delaying this decision?
Kelmendi: Given that we are not dealing with a legal matter, because this action is not based either on the legal aspects of France’s domestic laws, under which the Court of Colmar must act, or on the European Convention on Extradition, it has nothing to do with justice. Responsibility for this case has already been established by an international court, of which France was also a member. When we are not dealing with justice, the reason is political. Therefore, in this case, it is up to the Government of Kosovo to take a greater interest in this matter and take tougher measures toward the French state, because we are dealing with two sovereign and independent states that have recognized one another.
What should Kosovo’s institutions do in this case?
Kelmendi: The foreign ministers, justice ministers, and interior ministers of both countries should get in touch with one another; the presidency should also make contact, and concrete action should be sought to put an end to such actions, which, in my view, are political in nature. Legally, I see no basis for Mr. Haradinaj to have been detained by the French authorities in the first place, let alone for these unnecessary postponements to continue. So, this is a political act that Paris knows best. I think the situation in Europe as a whole has been in flux since Trump came to power. We are seeing major shifts in interstate relations at a time when the EU is sliding toward being undermined and perhaps, in the future, even dissolved. NATO is also in question. So, we are dealing with a phase in which new relations between states are being formed—relations which, in my view, are new historical traditions going back 200 years. I believe this is also where we should look for the basis of this political action being taken by the Court of Colmar against Ramush Haradinaj.
The court’s justification for postponing its decision was that it needed more time to examine the file submitted by Serbia. Do you think Serbia is holding French justice hostage?
Kelmendi: France is not a hostage of Serbia; it is a leader in such matters. As I mentioned earlier, we are dealing with old relationships. The Court of Colmar has no need to deal with cases like this, since the International Court in The Hague dealt with Ramush Haradinaj’s case for 10 years, during which there were hundreds of witnesses and pieces of evidence. The most distinguished international lawyers, appointed by the UN Security Council, of which France was also a member, concluded that Ramush Haradinaj was innocent of all those charges. Now we have the Court of Colmar, a provincial court, and it needs three weeks to analyze evidence that the International Court in The Hague adjudicated for ten years. This is ridiculous, in my view, from a legal standpoint. I think France is not a hostage of Serbia here; rather, France is leading the effort to consolidate the old, 200-year-old relations. We know France’s positions very well from history: at the Congress of Berlin, the London Conference, the Versailles Conference, during the Second World War, during the NATO bombings, and so on. We also know France’s positions regarding northern Kosovo. So, this is an action by Paris, which is pursuing two tracks: preserving the EU with Germany, Italy, Austria, and the other EU countries, and, on the other track, putting into action the old relations France had in the past with certain Balkan states and Russia.
France has been an ally of Kosovo, being among the first countries to recognize its declaration of independence. Could such actions damage the good relations between the two countries?
Kelmendi: France’s recognition of Kosovo as an independent and sovereign state was a necessary act. I think France was compelled to take such an action, not because it loved Kosovo so much. Here I want to step away from the issue of Ramush. In 1998, before the NATO bombing took place, when the five zones within Kosovo were divided, northern Kosovo, which is problematic now, was designated to be under U.S. control. But for this to happen—to carry out the bombing in NATO’s name—the United States had to give up that position and make way for France to control this area. In this way, I think France has never abandoned its political positions from the past or its good relations with Belgrade, Athens, and other countries. So, relations between Pristina and Paris have not been particularly good. They have been normal relations, based on mutual respect. Paris has not done much to build the state of Kosovo. I think the Government of Kosovo should summon the French ambassador in Pristina and ask, through him, that France show consideration toward Kosovo and maintain the normal relations they have had up to now. In this regard, Kosovo needs to act on two fronts: the Government of Kosovo’s dealings with France and the continuation of protests at home and abroad.
















