The executive director of the Kosovar Institute for Local Government, Besnik Tahiri, has stressed that Prime Minister Isa Mustafa knows best how the capital functions without the approval of the Law on Pristina. Therefore, he expects the Prime Minister to approve the Law on Pristina during this legislature and submit it for consideration to the Assembly of Kosovo. In […]
Tahiri: The Prime Minister knows best how difficult it is for Pristina to function without a law

The executive director of the Kosovar Institute for Local Government, Besnik Tahiri, has stressed that Prime Minister Isa Mustafa knows best how the capital functions without the approval of the Law on Pristina.
Therefore, he expects the Prime Minister to approve the Law on Pristina during this legislature and submit it for consideration to the Assembly of Kosovo.
In an interview with Ekonomia Online, Tahiri said that the failure to approve the Law on Pristina has caused great damage to the capital.
“Prime Minister Mustafa must certainly submit this law; he is obliged to submit it because he knows best how difficult it is to govern this city without a law, and I expect him to do so during this legislature…,” Tahiri said, adding that there should be coordination between the two entities, Mayor Ahmeti and Prime Minister Mustafa, and that the law should be submitted to the Assembly.
Tahiri also spoke about the performance of Kosovo’s municipalities during 2016, saying it had not been an easy year, as some municipalities had serious problems and legal ambiguities related to sectoral and secondary issues.
“The legal ambiguities are directly related to the topics that mayors promised during election campaigns. You know that the vast majority of mayors based their platforms only on investments made directly by the municipality, but also on local economic development, public-private partnerships, and, why not, the engagement of the private sector,” he said.
He also spoke about the budget allocation for municipalities, saying that in this respect the Ministry of Finance should revise the Law on Local Government Finance, rather than allocating the budget based on party preferences.
“It is beyond question that when parties come to power, they prefer their own party colleague. But is that right? It is completely unfair. From what perspective should we discuss this? We are bound by the criteria-based approach. It is unfair for a citizen of a particular area to be discriminated against because the mayor is not from a particular party. This must be stopped, because it will set a very bad precedent,” Tahiri said.
As for running for mayor of the Municipality of Pristina, Tahiri stressed that he would not run, but said the capital needs a courageous mayor who makes decisions, is close to citizens and is incorruptible.
“Pristina needs a mayor who is close to the people and incorruptible, because there are many opportunities for corruption here: there are many contracts and many contracting opportunities. Above all, it needs a citizen who looks beyond the present to the city’s growth and development,” Tahiri said.
He stressed that this year citizens would make their decisions largely based on the candidates’ platforms and how specific they are. “The race will be close and very interesting, and I look forward to seeing it…”
In this interview, Tahiri also speaks about decentralization, the functioning of the northern municipalities and other issues.
FULL INTERVIEW

EO: How do you assess the performance of Kosovo’s municipalities during 2016?
Tahiri: 2016 was not an easy year for Kosovo’s municipalities. I can say that there was progress in some areas, but some municipalities had serious problems. By progress, I mean the administration and the services it has professionalized in its dealings with citizens. Some municipalities have only just begun providing documents through online platforms and kiosks, which have reduced queues in municipal offices. However, small and medium-sized municipalities operate with limited capacity; I would say that they have responsibilities that are not necessarily entirely in the municipality’s hands. 2016 can be characterized by lower investment from the central government at the local level, while at the same time it can be characterized as the year in which municipalities implemented the greatest number of their plans, because it was a pre-election year, and in that sense activity increases during a pre-election year.
EO: The analyses produced by your Institute show that local government faces many legal ambiguities regarding its work. Do you think municipalities are fulfilling their legal obligations to citizens?
Tahiri: The legal ambiguities are directly related to the topics that mayors promised during election campaigns. You know that the vast majority of mayors based their platforms only on investments made directly by the municipality, but also on local economic development, public-private partnerships and, why not, the engagement of the private sector. In this respect, our Institute has seen that municipalities are powerless when it comes to local economic development and creating new jobs. If a public-private partnership is established, that decision is subject to a series of prior approvals by the central government and line ministries. This means municipalities continue to operate on an unclear legal basis regarding the main issues that shape people’s lives, in this case the investments that should come from the private sector. And when we see that public property held by municipalities is very limited, we understand that this has prevented municipalities from having a local economic development plan. The ambiguities are also related to sectoral laws: while the Law on Local Government precisely regulates the functioning and powers, there are also secondary laws that harm the work of municipalities. The forestry economy is in the hands of the central government. Municipalities protect the forests, while the central government receives the revenues generated by the forestry economy. We can talk about public-private partnerships; we can talk about a series of approvals by line ministries. Municipalities cannot do anything, even though they look very powerful on paper, but in practice they are very weak.
EO: Do you think the budget allocation made for each municipality is always fair and in the interests of citizens?
Tahiri: There are two ways of allocating the budget. The first is based on a per-capita formula, and in this way the latest census has discriminated against municipalities to a great extent in the revenues they receive under this criterion, because first of all municipalities receive budgets not according to the actual population, but according to the number of registered residents. Take Vitia, for example: it may receive a budget for 25,000 fewer people. But take Pristina, which has more people and receives funding for fewer than 200,000 residents. Or take the municipality of Parteš, which receives a budget for about 2,000 residents, although there are around 5,000 residents there, because the Serbs were not registered, and so on. In this respect, the budget is fair in the sense that municipalities receive funding based on population. However, where there are shortcomings and manipulation of the budget is mainly in the way line ministries allocate funding for municipal projects. To explain this: 10% of Kosovo’s budget goes to municipalities through this grant, while around 30% of Kosovo’s budget goes to capital investments by line ministries. So the question arises: while we have an accurate per-capita criterion for allocating the budget, what is the budget allocated by the line ministries? There are two criteria here: a political criterion based on political preferences, and a criterion based on the influence of a particular mayor in securing a particular budget. This means they need to have “political preference” and specific projects. Most municipalities are dissatisfied with this allocation of the local government budget, and what I want to say is that the Ministry of Finance needs to revise the Law on Local Government Finance. The Law on Local Government should be reviewed, as should the system itself, and our Institute has some suggestions. First, small municipalities cannot function with this budget; they will go bankrupt because they lack a tax base that would generate their own revenues and bring money into the municipality. Therefore, it is crucial that we review local government financing. Should we classify municipalities? It is an idea to classify municipalities as small, medium or large. As an institute, we are against a regional tier, but we support a real discussion. We believe, however, that there should not be an intermediate tier. Still, from a development perspective, it is crucial that this happens. I think a proper debate would be possible if we considered how to make the new municipalities we have established, or the small municipalities that already exist, more efficient. This would happen if it were not based on the per-capita budget, but instead municipalities formed localities. On this basis, we are discussing the matter first with the board of experts on local government and then with the Ministry of Finance, which has a very important role in financing what falls under municipal competence. It makes no sense to call a system decentralized if, along with responsibilities, the funding to carry them out is not also devolved to municipalities. If authority, powers and finances are not devolved equally, then service delivery fails. Finally, what I want to say about this is that we need to clearly understand that in a system of government like Kosovo’s, we have a single-tier system of government: from central government we move down to the municipality, which acts on behalf of the state for citizens. In this system, if the municipality gets results, then the state is definitely successful, and if the municipality gets no results, then the state fails. And this is the hypothesis we discuss: how successful Kosovo has been, based on the results municipalities produce.
EO: You also outlined ways to reform budget allocation, but do you think Kosovo has so far allocated its budget along party lines?
Tahiri: Honestly, yes. It is beyond question that when parties come to power, they prefer their own party colleague. But is that right? It is completely unfair. From what perspective should we discuss this? We are bound by the criteria-based approach. It is unfair for a citizen of a particular area to be discriminated against because the mayor is not from a particular party. This must be stopped, because it will set a very bad precedent: whenever the state’s budget changes—and the same party is not always in power, especially in a democratic system, where parties change—we are creating a precedent and justification for investment preferences to change whenever the government changes. That is why it is important to redesign the financing of municipalities and local government, and to conduct an accurate analysis of the criteria that should be in place when we plan capital investments in municipalities.
EO: You are considered one of the best experts on local government in Kosovo. Do you think Pristina needs a candidate like you, who knows local government so well?
What I can say is this: in Pristina, the role of the political party is very significant. First of all, Pristina needs a mayor who is down to earth, in the sense of being very close to citizens; a mayor who has the courage to make decisions, and one who sees the capital beyond what is called in English “doing usual business.” Pristina cannot be compared with Hani i Elezit, even though we are governed by law, nor can it be compared with Obiliq, even though it is governed by law. Pristina is a very great source of opportunities and can generate substantial revenues of its own. At the time, I presented the legalization process as an opportunity, but there are many opportunities for expansion. Pristina needs a mayor who is close to the people and incorruptible. Why do I say incorruptible? Because there are many opportunities for corruption here: there are many contracts and many contracting opportunities. Above all, it needs a citizen who looks beyond the present to the city’s growth and development. What I want to say about this year is that it is very important. I think citizens will base their decisions largely on the candidates’ platforms and how specific they are. The race will be close and very interesting, and I look forward to seeing it. I will be glad to watch.
EO: Despite what you have declared—that you will not run for mayor of Pristina—do you think you would change Pristina if you were mayor?
Tahiri: To be honest, Pristina has changed over these years. If we look at Pristina immediately after the war, it has changed… We cannot say that nothing has been done, because that would be wrong. Is such change enough? If I were in that position, I would do things differently, but the citizens prevented me from going further in explaining… through their vote. In a political party, the vote is power. You can be a great expert, very accessible, but if you don’t have votes, you don’t have political legitimacy or democratic legitimacy. In this sense, I think good work has been done in Pristina, by comparison. But Pristina needs more; it needs a higher vision in relation to the responsibilities of every mayor.
EO: Has there been such a vision until now?
Tahiri: There has been. Look, if we analyze all the mayors, and look at Shpend, we see that he has made deep reforms in the administration. He is a mayor who, nevertheless, has not been implicated in any misuse, and who has a fairly proactive approach toward citizens. Is that enough? No, it is not enough. I think we spoke with Shpend in 2013, and at the time I was very much in favor of a coalition happening because of the power of the assembly. Remember that big cities need an assembly; they need the municipal assembly because strategic decisions are made there: public-private partnerships, the budget, regulations, enterprises, and so on. I think that was where there was a weakness. If we look at what happened during Mustafa’s term, there were some quite significant infrastructure investments. You know, now I’ve had to walk along the connection to Pejton and the Dardania neighborhood; it is a very good underpass. The squares have been expanded, and some infrastructure improvements have been made. Discussions about the water factory also began during his term. And what I always mention about Ismet Beqiri is that he was the one who had the courage to build the square for us. I remember we were in a panic because people said the paving stones were radioactive, but at least he had the courage to build the first square, which gave us some opportunity to enjoy Pristina from that perspective. In this sense, everyone has done their part. Is it enough? I am not satisfied, because in general I expect more; I am more ambitious. Pristina should have expanded. The congestion in Pristina is due to people initially granting permits for large buildings in the center instead of thinking about expansion and gradually preserving the center while expanding, in order to give it room to breathe, and so on. Still, in this assessment, I think some things have been done, but it is not enough.
EO: Is the Law on Pristina being held hostage by politics?
Tahiri: We have said many times that this law has caused great damage to Pristina. Recently, our Institute prepared a concept paper on what we would like the law to look like. First of all, what I suggested was that the mayor’s fiscal powers should be increased and fiscal decentralization expanded, because this would generate more revenue and, on that basis, strengthen the implementation of programs and capital projects. Second, we thought the municipal mayor should have more capacity in terms of staff, because he manages capital investments on a scale comparable to three ministries. A minister has six advisers and three other staff members, while the mayor has only one or two. On this basis, responsibility must be assigned. Then we spoke a lot about the role of the assembly. We think the Pristina Municipal Assembly should be designated as the Assembly of the Capital. The Assembly of the Capital should have a presiding officer who is a representative; in this case, one should be elected according to the same principle as the Assembly of Kosovo. At the same time, assembly members should have… a full-time job and a salary equivalent to what a department director earns today, because we think they should be the ones who, in addition to working on committees, oversee and monitor the work of the sectors, not just the mayor. It is easiest to insult the mayor; in these systems, you always have people who are satisfied with mayors and people who are dissatisfied. In this sense, the role of the Pristina Assembly—the Assembly of the Capital—should also be to monitor departments. We have therefore thought that six permanent committees in the Pristina Assembly should oversee the sectors, and on this basis make the assembly a workplace. To be honest, its role has been devalued, not because these people lack political power—each person in the assembly was elected directly from an open list—but because, in terms of both their power and finances, they receive a salary of around 120 euros, at most 150 euros. They neither have it as a workplace nor have the performance they should. So in this sense, the assembly and other elements related mainly to the use of the additional budget supplement provided by the Law on Pristina should be discussed.
EO: Is the failure to approve this law preventing Pristina from functioning as a capital?
Tahiri: Absolutely. Today I was at the Palace of Youth. The land belongs to the municipality, the investment was made by citizens, and the Kosovo Privatization Agency manages it; it has been left to decay for 17 years. Please, we cannot afford to keep dealing with a building in the heart of the city without a clear decision. We have to discuss what to do with it: should it be returned to municipal ownership, or should we discuss how to manage it? It is intolerable. There are many other things that, in the absence of the law… if there were a law, we would bring the Pristina Assembly back into the Assembly, and we would be much more active.
EO: Why is this happening? Why is this law not being approved?
Tahiri: I don’t know, to be honest; I don’t have an explanation. It is ridiculous, it is terrible.
EO: While he was mayor of Pristina, the Prime Minister always criticized the government for not approving the Law on Pristina….
Tahiri: Prime Minister Mustafa must certainly submit this law; he is obliged to submit it because he knows best how difficult it is to govern this city without a law, and I expect him to do so…
EO: Why has he not submitted it until now…?
Tahiri: We do not have accurate information. What we know is that a concept paper is under discussion; we know that the Ministry of Local Government has formed a working group; we know there has been an effort to communicate between the capital and the ministry, but I cannot say more. What I want to say is that there should be coordination between the two entities, in this case Mayor Ahmeti and Prime Minister Mustafa, and that it should be submitted… It is very important that this pass during this legislature.
EO: Decentralization in Kosovo has a political approach, so it needs to be reconsidered. What are these aspects?
Tahiri: Decentralization came about as a result of the Ahtisaari Plan. Not only decentralization, but also the establishment of municipalities and their responsibilities came about as a result of the Ahtisaari Plan. It is now more necessary than ever to discuss this issue, and I will explain why. First, when we built our political and governing systems, we did so on the principle that municipalities should be established to function, more or less, as temporary administrations, so that the construction of a democratic state with elected institutions could begin. This was done through Regulation 2000/45, which UNMIK introduced at the time. We operated under this regulation until 2007. In 2007 we had another regulation, as I recall, 2007/30, which for the first time enabled competition through direct democracy, with citizens choosing the mayor. However, the premise, the arrangement of municipalities, was still based mainly on ethnic and political considerations; there was no clear development vision. What happened was that 17 years ago we built a system primarily to accommodate humanitarian needs, the return of refugees—more than one million refugees were abroad—and to address very social issues. In 2007, we had a situation in which we were discussing mainly the premise of building a multiethnic state, so that this concept could serve as justification for passing a new resolution, which did not pass. Today, ten years later, there is no debate about what the system should look like. We must review the system in depth. The state administration must be reviewed, redesigned and turned into a tool or host for the country’s development, because we have not had the time to do that until now. From 2000 to 2007, we were occupied with state-building; in 2007, with justifying independence and the provisions we needed in order to declare independence. There has been no debate since then. The time is now; this is the last train to discuss the state administration on the basis of the state’s role in development, and not the state’s role in accommodating minorities.
EO: How much are municipalities without mayors from the governing parties harmed by budget allocations?
Tahiri: I am saying that the absence of the Law on Pristina has harmed Pristina, and the absence of a finance law that treats small municipalities as a problem has harmed them. We are talking about around 13 small municipalities with serious problems. Then there are political investments, which have also discriminated against them to a great extent. What we advocate as an institute is that the system be fundamentally reviewed, so that the state administration becomes a mechanism for developing the country, not administering it. In other words, over the years we have built an administration that administers Kosovo, the municipality and the ministry, but not a strong state and a strong administration that develops the country. The premises in these debates have therefore been wrong, and we need to act on that basis.
EO: How should the integration of the municipalities of North Mitrovica be carried out?
Tahiri: The north of Kosovo is not integrated. We have some institutions, such as the police and customs, that function, but vital services for citizens—education, healthcare and infrastructure investment, and so on—are provided by parallel structures. It is true that we have a municipality that derives from local elections and a mayor elected under the laws of the Republic of Kosovo, but these mayors have never respected their own state as they should. So what are we to do? We are 17 years after the war, and the north is still not integrated. I think an investment and services strategy needs to be developed for this part of Kosovo. Bringing the north back under control through conflict or by means other than services and capital investment is impossible. The only way is to make state services good and gradually make them accessible, and I think Kosovo has failed in that part. A strategy must be developed to bring that part back, and when I say strategy, I mean someone who knows the field well. If we go to North Mitrovica, we see that cars still operate without license plates, the institutions still bear no sign of the state of Kosovo, and the cars are still like they were in Tito’s time. There are changes that are similar, and when we accept this compromise, we need to think carefully. In my opinion, Serbia does not want the partition of Kosovo; it does not want territory it already controls, because the Serbian state controls the north of Kosovo through parallel structures. It wants to weaken Kosovo and portray it as a failed state, including in the negotiations in Brussels, but it has no intention of partitioning Kosovo. Rather, it intends always to gain something in negotiations for its own purposes—who knows, a wall, a train or some trivial issue—just to gain something. We must do everything possible to integrate that part of Kosovo.
EO: You said Kosovo has failed in that part. Does that mean Kosovo itself is dividing the north?
Tahiri: No, Kosovo is not dividing it. We, as Kosovo, have done our part; I am speaking in legal terms. We are a state declared to be a democratic, multiethnic state, and since we are a multiethnic society—90% Albanian and 10% minorities—we have embraced this multiethnic system because our society is multiethnic. We have taken our step forward. Secondly, through the dialogue process over all these years, we have failed to enter the institutions; we have not been able to make use of these municipalities and these mayors. We should have gone in with direct investment. Investments in that area are actually quite scarce.
Interviewed by: Kaltrina Zymberi
















