Ekonomia Online
LATEST

Socrates Facing Trump

Socrates Facing Trump

For Michael Sandel, the idea that the populist wave depends only on immigration and the economy is wrong. “Those who think this way fail to see that there are, first and foremost, moral and cultural reasons. And my concern,” he repeats, “is that liberal elites cannot understand this.” This 64-year-old American political philosopher, author of “Liberalism and the Limits of Justice” and his most recent book, “What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets,” gives lectures at Harvard with legendary clarity. One of his courses on justice has been clicked on YouTube seven and a half million times.

For Michael Sandel, the idea that the populist wave depends only on immigration and the economy is wrong. “Those who think this way fail to see that there are, first and foremost, moral and cultural reasons. And my concern,” he repeats, “is that liberal elites cannot understand this.” This 64-year-old American political philosopher, author of “Liberalism and the Limits of Justice” and his most recent book, “What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets,” gives lectures at Harvard with legendary clarity. One of his courses on justice has been clicked on YouTube seven and a half million times.

A protagonist in the philosophical battle between liberals such as John Rawls and communitarians such as MacIntyre and Taylor, he has contributed to a shift in political philosophy toward positions more accepting of cultural differences and citizens’ traditions in the public sphere. At the Davos Forum, he used the metaphor of the skybox (the name for luxury boxes in baseball stadiums). A gulf separates those at the top from ordinary people.

There were no students in Davos, but there was the skybox of politics and economics. What did you tell them?

That they have not understood the meaning of the populist protest. The problem does not arise only from unemployment and fear of immigrants, but from the loss of esteem and progressive changes in social and political identity. The protest has terrible and dangerous aspects, but it is rooted in legitimate grievances on the part of those who feel weakened by three decades of neoliberal globalization. The passion and dissatisfaction that give populism its strength have to do with the loss of status, the contempt suffered by the middle class, workers, ordinary people.

Did they understand you?

I have no illusions.

Your criticisms of the limits of liberalism have a long history, going back to the 1980s. But which liberalism?

I wrote as a critic of liberalism, but as a friendly critic, arguing against the thesis that liberal public discourse should not focus on fundamental questions concerning what constitutes a good life, and that government and the law should remain neutral toward competing conceptions of how the good should be understood.

What were the main objections?

There were two: first, that you cannot define fundamental questions of justice without engaging with different conceptions of the good life; second, that keeping what is good out of public discourse creates a vacuum concerning what matters to citizens, excluding their voices on important issues. This exclusion triggers an unwelcome backlash: some fill the void with intolerant views.

Is that what we see today?

Exactly: a populist revolt against a technocratic and managerial form of public discourse, identified with a triumphalist faith in the market, which has outsourced political and moral judgment. This process began in the 1980s with Reagan and Thatcher, but continued under center-left parties: Clinton, Blair, and Schröder certainly moderated their faith in the market on the one hand, but consolidated it on the other. The promise that market mechanisms are the primary instruments for achieving the public good was never called into question.

But a certain neutrality in the concept of the good keeps authoritarianism in check.

Since the 1980s, I have naturally faced this objection, and I have always answered that I am right in my thesis: if a neutral public discourse cannot give us the principles for a just society, then this insistence has been perceived as a demand for suppression, and as dishonest too, because people know that the decisions being made do not await their voices.

This protest takes forms that are far from liberal

The paradoxical effect is that the liberalism of neutrality, which arises above all from the aim of avoiding the risk of authoritarianism, in fact creates the conditions for authoritarian politics, because it produces a backlash against liberal elites that has taken two forms: religious fundamentalism and right-wing populist nationalism, another way of dressing a naked public sphere.

In the closing lines of your book “Democracy’s Discontent,” twenty years ago, you said that “human beings are made to tell stories” and, as a result, rebel against the liberal tendency to eliminate narratives. But how can narrative and freedom be reconciled?

It is the challenge of our time. The central theme of politics is belonging to a community and what it means. As democratic citizens of pluralistic societies, we live within a plurality of communities, and our identities are defined in many ways. This means that we must work together to draw what we need from narratives and traditions.

But in a tolerant society, how can this encounter respect pluralism?

There are two different ways of approaching the question of mutual respect. One is “avoidance” of one another. This pushes us to find ways to reason openly about differences and encourages all citizens not to leave their moral and spiritual convictions outside the public sphere, but to enter as they are, fully “equipped” with their traditions, cultures, and moral convictions.

Why does the populist revolt hit progressive parties harder?

Because they have been seen as more closely connected to professional and technocratic elites than to ordinary people, who formed their base. To reinvigorate the social democratic project, the meaning, scope, and dignity of work must first be reimagined. Second, the meaning of the national community must be valued, without allowing patriotism to become the monopoly of populists.

Your clarity in your lectures is legendary. How have you managed it?

I fell in love with philosophy late, after graduating. Many philosophers are essentially oriented toward other philosophers; I try to connect philosophy with life. Socrates walked the streets of Athens talking with ordinary people: he began with basic questions and led them to grapple with fundamental questions of justice and the good. I try to imitate that model, in my own way. (bota.al)

Related