LDK parliamentary candidate Muhamet Mustafa has raised the alarm over the large number of ballots, calling for an investigation. So far, Mustafa says, this problem is not troubling anyone. According to the economics professor, there are several reasons why this process continues to be ignored. Mustafa explains in an interview with […]
Mustafa: It’s strange that nobody is concerned about the invalid ballots

LDK parliamentary candidate Muhamet Mustafa has raised the alarm over the large number of ballots, calling for an investigation. So far, Mustafa says, this problem is not troubling anyone. According to the economics professor, there are several reasons why this process continues to be ignored. Mustafa explains in an interview with lajmi.net what is wrong with this process.
Lajmi.net: Where do you think the flaw lies that so many ballots have been invalid, as well as there being problems with recounting votes for candidates within the lists?
Mustafa: This needs to be investigated in order to provide an accurate, comprehensive assessment, although some of the flaws are not unknown, since they have accompanied almost all national and local elections. Unfortunately, instead of diminishing, these flaws are growing increasingly serious, severely damaging the voting process and its credibility. So perhaps it would be better to call them serious distortions rather than accompanying and sporadic flaws. Strangely, this is not greatly troubling either the public or other actors, especially civil society and other responsible parties. As for the political parties, they do not seem to care about this; it appears to suit them to have an instrument here and there that they can use as needed and according to their preferences to advance the interests of individuals or particular interest groups. The flaw may lie in many areas: the nature of relations within political parties, their low level of democratic and political culture, the complicated electoral system, indifference to pursuing violations of electoral law, and the tolerance shown toward all this by those responsible for preventing it. This resembles the ostrich-like behavior of many people. The fact that only 14 people were found guilty and brought before the law amid all this “chaos” illustrates the ostrich example more than the opposite.
Lajmi.net: You have raised the alarm several times and called for an investigation into what you call distortions.?
Mustafa: I have tried to bring this issue to the fore and make it a subject of debate. Some of my posts on social media were also carried by online media; that was a kind of result, but nothing more. Apparently, to draw attention you have to insult someone, and do so harshly—and even then, you must use their first and last name! So, as I said above, this issue did not become a subject of debate anywhere else. Encouraged by a statement from the chair of the CEC, who said there were problems with counting votes for candidates within the lists, and also by a comment from a commissioner on one of my posts that demonstrated the mechanics of this trick, three colleagues and I filed a submission with the Elections Complaints and Appeals Panel (ECAP). After receiving their negative response, we also took it to the Supreme Court, where we received an almost copy-paste reply: You have not substantiated your claims. As if these two things were not evidence. Since we did not make the complaint exclusively about an individual grievance, we cited the arguments above and asked for a standard research method to be used on a random sample, generated by computer program: a sample of 248 ballot boxes to be recounted and investigated, out of the 2,900 or more ballot boxes containing ballots. This would establish the scale of the invalid-ballot phenomenon and the “redistribution” of votes between candidates, and compare it with the processes and results recorded at polling stations. This would show precisely whether the voting results had been distorted and, if so, by what percentage, and on that basis assess the credibility of the vote count and representation in the Assembly. They replied that this method was not provided for by law (!?). Correct, but it was not prohibited either, and those bodies are responsible for doing everything to ensure the credibility of elections. The fact that, among 116 ballot boxes recounted on the basis of individual complaints, three MPs declared winners according to the polling-station records had to be replaced did not suffice for them! This was a highly significant indication supporting our claims, but it cannot be used to draw conclusions about the process as a whole, since those 116 boxes were not a sample selected using a standard random methodology that would make them representative of all ballot boxes. It seems to me there was greater concern about closing everything as quickly as possible than about testing the credibility of representation in the highest democratic institution, which makes decisions on the country’s most important issues.
Lajmi.net: You received a response from DnV. Do you think this response settles the problem, or should the search for the truth continue?
Mustafa: Yes, I called on DnV to make a public statement, since they had pledged before the public to monitor the process, and this concerned the very large number of invalid ballots. It can be called a worrying number—in fact, it has risen from around 30,000 in the 2014 elections to nearly 50,000 in this June’s elections. After some time they responded, more specifically their leader, Mr. Kryeziu, presenting research they called preliminary (meaning it would be followed by more serious analysis) and saying that, as far as they knew, there was no cause for concern. Nevertheless, they said something very important: they said they could monitor the quality of the vote-counting process very little, if at all, whether for invalid ballots or votes for candidates. This meant that everything was at the mercy of the commissioners. Commissioners can of course make mistakes due to fatigue, but even after being engaged for years, the possibility that they may be influenced by individual or group interests, and by an agreement along the lines of “you work for your party and I’ll work for mine,” cannot be ruled out. Why, for instance, shouldn’t commissioners from Podujeva go to Gjakova and vice versa, and why shouldn’t ballots be scanned and the process digitized? This would not increase costs that much, and would ensure the credibility of the count. Is this an oversight that amounts to “nothing,” or does this kind of system suit the political parties?
Lajmi.net: Would electoral reform solve this problem?
Mustafa: It could significantly reduce, at least, this “redistribution” of votes within the lists of political entities if voting were conducted using lists in electoral districts. For example, there would be a list only for candidates in one municipality which, based on the number of residents, would receive four seats in the Assembly, and candidates from electoral entities would compete for those seats. In this case each party, with its own commissioners, would ensure that “this redistribution” did not happen. Electronic counting and digitizing the process are another solution for overcoming or reducing these distortions to tolerable levels. There is no justification for not using electronic counting even in the existing electoral system.
Lajmi.net: What role do you think the CEC should play in this case?
Mustafa: The CEC bears the greatest responsibility, though it is not the only one, for the credibility of the electoral system. Given its experience from previous elections, the large number of invalid ballots, and, as the chair herself said, problems with counting votes for candidates, it should have proposed and implemented more effective measures to address them.
Lajmi.net: Has the CEC done its job, given that this institution has been considered to have failed to inform citizens sufficiently?
The CEC could certainly have done more to explain how to vote, but it cannot do all the work alone. The political parties and the media should also have done more, with a more comprehensive information campaign and voter instructions, which would certainly have reduced the number of invalid ballots.
Lajmi.net: Why did you give up politics, given that you have contributed to Kosovo’s politics and also to the Assembly?
Mustafa: More accurately, as I said in my public statement, I have given up direct work in parliamentary, government or party institutions. I have made the reasons for this public. But I have never said that I am giving up politics. I will continue to work on politics, especially economic policy, through the three projects I have announced: research on economic and development policies and advocacy for them within the Riinvest Institute; civic engagement in the Pristina Citizens’ Forum, which is currently being formed; and the Albanian Center for Strategic Studies, based in Tirana, which we founded with a group of academic colleagues and professionals from Pristina, Tirana and Macedonia. So I remain deeply engaged and concerned with politics, especially economic and development policies, from a platform other than direct work in institutions, believing that I will be more effective there and remaining open to offering our recommendations to any government or parliamentary formation elected by the Assembly, provided, of course, that it is open to such cooperation. Thank you very much for this conversation, lajmi.net.
















