The President of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers, Ekatarina Trendafilova, told BIRN that the new court is not ethnically biased, will protect its witnesses from intimidation and will deliver justice impartially and independently. In her first interview as President of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers, Judge […]
Trendafilova: I promise impartial justice

The President of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers, Ekatarina Trendafilova, told BIRN that the new court is not ethnically biased, will protect its witnesses from intimidation and will deliver justice impartially and independently.
In her first interview as President of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers, Judge Ekatarina Trendafilova told BIRN that the newly established court based in The Hague, which will try former members of the Kosovo Liberation Army, will not be ethnically biased because it will try only suspected criminals, not the guerrilla organisation itself.
Trendafilova also promised that the court would properly protect witnesses – a failure in previous efforts to try Kosovo Liberation Army fighters – and expressed hope that its work would help strengthen the rule of law in Kosovo.
This is not the first time Trendafilova has ruled in international criminal justice cases. Before joining the Kosovo Specialist Chambers, she was a judge at the International Criminal Court, an experience she believes will benefit her in her new role.
BIRN: Other hybrid courts have operated in Kosovo before. How is this court different from the others, and how will you, as a judge, ensure that the court fulfils its mandate?
Trendafilova: The Specialist Chambers are different in many respects. I will mention some of them, but I will not use words such as ‘hybrid’, ‘international’ or ‘internationalised’. The Specialist Chambers were established through a constitutional amendment adopted by the Kosovo Assembly with a two-thirds majority. This is an empowering factor for us. It means that the people of Kosovo, through their representatives in the Assembly, expressed their will that such an institution is necessary and desirable.
Secondly, the Specialist Chambers can rely on Kosovo authorities, including the police, in relation to the execution of orders, searches and seizures, and the arrest of suspects. Under the Law, Kosovo authorities are required to cooperate with the Specialist Chambers in achieving the overarching goal of bringing to justice those responsible for serious crimes alleged to have been committed.
On the other hand, we are an institution relocated to the Netherlands, the host state, which means that we can ensure the highest level of security for everyone who has dealings with the Specialist Chambers, particularly victims and witnesses.
In addition, only international judges may sit on the Specialist Chambers. This arrangement shows that the Kosovo Assembly paid the utmost respect to the independence and integrity of this institution, the criminal proceedings to be conducted by it, and the security of victims and witnesses.
As a judge and as President of the Specialist Chambers, I will ensure that the Specialist Chambers fulfil their mandate by implementing the Law adopted by the Kosovo Assembly and the Rules adopted by the judges. Most importantly, I would like to emphasise that I am confident that the judges appointed to the Roster of International Judges, who have extensive experience, will conduct exemplary judicial proceedings and deliver decisions of the highest quality.
BIRN: How will you address the problem of communicating and explaining the mission of the Specialist Chambers, given the ICTY’s poor reputation in the former Yugoslavia, but also considering the reluctance towards this new institution in Kosovo?
Trendafilova: Perhaps not everyone in Kosovo supports or opposes the Specialist Chambers. In any case, as I said in an earlier answer to your question, the decision to establish the Specialist Chambers was made by the representatives of the people of Kosovo, the Assembly.
We are a reality, we are now functioning and can receive submissions. Our mandate differs from that of the ICTY, and we should be judged on the work we do.
Alongside the establishment of our institution and our readiness to commence judicial proceedings, it is equally important that the public continues to be informed about our mandate, the procedures and the possible outcomes expected from the work of our institution. This is important to prevent distorted information or misunderstandings.
I strongly support the greatest possible transparency regarding our activities, with the exception, of course, of sensitive and confidential information necessary to protect witnesses who will come to testify.
Since last year and the launch of our three-language website, where all information can be found in English, Albanian and Serbian, all important information and public submissions by the parties and judges have been made accurately available to the public, and this will continue.
Communication with the media is an ongoing process. In addition, senior court officials, as well as the Specialist Chambers’ public information team, have regularly engaged with various important stakeholders from civil society, academia and the media in Kosovo, as well as more broadly in the region and around the world.
For example, this spring the Registrar, Dr Fidelma Donlon, held a meeting in Pristina with numerous media and civil society representatives at the Justice Transparency Forum. I expect similar events to continue to be organised in the future.
Recently, I also held a press conference at our headquarters. We also welcome many visitors and give lectures to groups of interested students. All these activities are part of implementing our communications programme, which will be intensified. We will arrange for future court sessions to be broadcast live.
I would like to emphasise that I rely to the greatest extent on communication to convince people in the region that the Specialist Chambers will deliver justice impartially and independently for everyone who has dealings with them.
BIRN: How difficult is communication when you are located so far from the place where the crimes were committed?
Trendafilova: I am fully aware of the difficulties that distance creates for effective communication and outreach. However, fortunately, we live in an age of modern technology, which I hope will help us establish direct communication with everyone concerned, and not only with the media.
One of our immediate priorities is to reach out to victims and fully explain their rights, as well as the relevant application process and the requirements for admission as a victim. Witnesses will also be given assurances regarding the robust protective measures taken by the Specialist Chambers.
Furthermore, once hearings begin, we will broadcast them on our website in all official languages, enabling the public and the media to follow them.
Naturally, in accordance with witness-protection needs, some broadcasts will be partial, or there will be broadcasts with protective measures such as alteration of the image and voice.
BIRN: How do the Specialist Chambers cooperate with Kosovo authorities? As regards detention and arrests, will you use a special court police force, the Dutch police or the Kosovo police?
Trendafilova: As provided for in the Law, we can rely on the Kosovo police, as well as any Kosovo court. In addition, the Specialist Prosecutor may execute his orders through a police force within his Office. Every order and decision of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers, including searches, seizures and arrests of suspects on the territory of Kosovo, must be implemented. The Law requires this. We may also request international cooperation if necessary.
BIRN: How sensitive do you need to be to the current political circumstances in Kosovo?
Trendafilova: It is not really a matter of sensitivity. The Specialist Chambers are an independent judicial institution in the exercise of their functions and fulfilment of their mandate, in accordance with the Law, which was agreed upon and adopted by an absolute majority of the Kosovo Assembly.
We carry out our mission as set out in the Law, independently of the political process in Kosovo. We are bound only by the Constitution and the law.
Nevertheless, we closely follow developments in Kosovo and are aware of sensitive issues, without being influenced by them.
BIRN: What is your response to criticism that the Specialist Chambers are biased and deal with only one ethnic group, Kosovo Albanians?
Trendafilova: The Specialist Chambers do not prosecute any ethnic group or organisation. The Specialist Chambers will prosecute and convict individuals only. The Law clearly defines individual criminal responsibility, which means that individuals will be convicted of criminal acts they committed as individuals and not as members of a group, ethnic community or any other group.
BIRN: The court also has a Victims’ Support Office, and the Law provides for reparation programmes. How will this work in practice?
Trendafilova: First, let me say that I am very pleased that, unlike the ICTY, the Specialist Chambers give victims the opportunity to participate in proceedings.
Victims of crimes referred to in an indictment may apply to the Victims’ Participation Office within the Registry if they wish to participate. The Law provides for victims’ rights to notification, recognition as a victim and reparation. In practice, this means that victims will be able to participate meaningfully in the Specialist Chambers’ proceedings and seek reparation.
After an accused is found guilty, judges may order that accused to pay appropriate compensation to victims, collectively or individually. The Victims’ Participation Office will also maintain a list of victims’ counsel to enable effective legal representation and assistance for victims.
BIRN: Can you also explain the role of the Ombudsperson?
Trendafilova: The inclusion of the Ombudsperson, which is also provided for in the Kosovo Constitution, is an important constitutional safeguard within the legal framework of the Specialist Chambers. The Ombudsperson is intended to ensure greater transparency and openness to the public on our part, and to serve as an independent monitor of the Specialist Chambers and the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office.
At the same time, the Ombudsperson will show due respect for the independence of the judiciary and judicial proceedings, which means that the Ombudsperson cannot interfere in their conduct, except in cases of undue delay.
Finally, the operation of the Ombudsperson is intended to strengthen the checks and balances that safeguard fundamental rights and freedoms, as enshrined in the Kosovo Constitution.
I look forward to this mechanism becoming operational, which will further contribute to the credibility of both institutions.
BIRN: So far, witness protection has been one of the key problems in war crimes trials in Kosovo, and the Specialist Chambers claim to have prepared a robust system for witness protection. What is your view of the approach taken thus far by international and domestic courts to protecting witnesses who testify about international crimes? Is this one of the reasons why courts are often located far from the place where the crimes were committed?
Trendafilova: Based on my past experience, and also being aware of several past cases, I am very conscious of the importance of witness protection. This is a key element of the Specialist Chambers’ mandate, as demonstrated by the fact that the proceedings have been relocated to the Netherlands.
For this reason, a robust witness-protection system has been established in our Rules of Procedure and Evidence. In addition, the Specialist Chambers will not tolerate any kind of interference with the security and well-being of witnesses and will prosecute such interference.
The relocation of proceedings is a powerful tool that offers better protection for witnesses, victims and other persons who have dealings with the Specialist Chambers.
I and all the judges have unwavering confidence, as expressed in the Rules, that justice will not be done at the expense of the security and well-being of any person cooperating with the Specialist Chambers. In a word, protection is key for us.
BIRN: What do you see as possible obstacles to the successful operation of the Specialist Chambers?
Trendafilova: I will address this question from a different perspective, namely, what factors can be used to measure the Specialist Chambers’ fulfilment of their mandate.
First, the persons whom the Specialist Prosecutor charges with serious crimes will have to be arrested or voluntarily surrender to face the charges against them. I hope that the Specialist Prosecutor will complete his investigative duties promptly and file indictments as soon as he is ready.
Secondly, accused persons will be guaranteed a fair and expeditious trial in accordance with the Kosovo Constitution and the highest standards of human rights.
Thirdly, victims’ rights will be effectively protected.
Fourthly, the Specialist Chambers and the trials conducted there will provide the people of Kosovo with an opportunity to confront the past.
Finally, by fulfilling their mandate, the Specialist Chambers will strengthen and advance the rule of law in Kosovo.
BIRN: You are an experienced judge who has previously worked at international courts. In your opinion, how useful will your experience at the International Criminal Court be for your work at the Kosovo Specialist Chambers?
Trendafilova: At the International Criminal Court, I worked on a number of cases in which I faced various legal and factual issues, as well as complex challenges requiring immediate action and appropriate, timely solutions.
The nine years I spent at the International Criminal Court, as well as my previous experience, provide a strong foundation for the duties entrusted to me at the Kosovo Specialist Chambers.
It is important to build on lessons learned and benefit from achievements that should not only be applied, but also further developed and improved in the day-to-day work of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers.
The same is true of all the judges on the Roster of International Judges, who have extensive domestic and international experience, including experience at international criminal courts.
As the newest institution prosecuting international crimes, we have a unique opportunity to avoid shortcomings that may have been encountered by other judicial institutions in their respective jurisdictions.
BIRN: In your view, in what ways can this court help advance criminal justice? Does this court have anything new that other courts could use?
Trendafilova: The structure of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers and the legal framework for the court’s work contain several innovations that could help advance criminal justice and could also serve as models for future institutional improvements.
In this regard, I would like to mention the Specialist Chamber of the Constitutional Court. This Chamber is part of our institution’s structure and is tasked with reviewing whether the Rules of Procedure and Evidence comply with the Kosovo Constitution and reflect the highest standards of human rights.
Another responsibility of this Chamber is to ensure the protection of the rights of individuals enshrined in the Constitution before the Specialist Chambers and against any action by the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office. Other criminal justice institutions prosecuting the same or similar crimes do not have this fundamental mechanism for safeguarding human rights.
In addition, the Ombudsperson is an innovation in our institution compared with international criminal courts. The Ombudsperson’s task is to monitor and protect the fundamental rights and freedoms enshrined in Chapter II of the Constitution of persons who have dealings with the Specialist Chambers and the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office, in accordance with the Law and the Rules.
Thirdly, the Kosovo Specialist Chambers aim to operate efficiently and effectively. For example, the Law does not provide for the permanent presence of judges at the Specialist Chambers’ headquarters, except where specific work requirements make it necessary.
The Law has also established a Roster of International Judges and an operating system in which the President has the authority to assign judges to different panels as needed.
We have also ensured precise case management and strict deadlines for judicial activity. These and many other methods agreed upon and adopted by the judges will make our institution efficient.
Some of these features derive from Kosovo’s judicial system, while others were introduced by the judges sitting in Plenary. These innovations can be studied and duly taken into consideration in future models of international criminal justice.
BIRN: Given the current crisis at the International Criminal Court and the creation of hybrid courts such as this one for Kosovo, or the court for the Central African Republic, do you think this is the future of international justice, or a temporary compromise?
Trendafilova: First, I do not agree that the International Criminal Court is in crisis. On the contrary, the first permanent international criminal court has been operating for almost 15 years and has become firmly established in the international arena.
The problems the International Criminal Court has with some member states may be seen as evidence that this institution is on the right path in the fight against horrific crimes that offend the conscience of humanity.
The strongest opposition comes from those who fear the moment when they will appear before this court.
Nevertheless, the existence of the International Criminal Court does not preclude the emergence of institutions of a different nature, such as the Specialist Chambers and the hybrid court for the Central African Republic, where the particular nature of the crimes and the problems to be addressed call for a different approach.
















