Proposal to mobilize domestic legal expertise and ensure coordinated institutional engagement by the Republic of Kosovo 1. The forthcoming battle is exclusively legal As the appeal phase against the first-instance judgment in the Kosovo Specialist Chambers approaches, it must be clearly understood that the forthcoming process represents one of the challenges […]
The Legal Battle to Defend the KLA Leaders in the Appeals Chambers of the Specialist Chambers

Proposal to mobilize domestic legal expertise and ensure coordinated institutional engagement by the Republic of Kosovo
1. The forthcoming battle is exclusively legal
As the appeal phase against the first-instance judgment in the Kosovo Specialist Chambers approaches, it must be clearly understood that the forthcoming process represents one of the most important legal, institutional and historical challenges for the Republic of Kosovo. At this stage, the battle must be waged first and foremost on the legal front, through professional arguments, concrete evidence, critical analysis of the judgment and identification of all possible substantive and procedural violations in the first-instance trial. Kosovo no longer has time to waste. We have no time for waiting, repeated political statements or debates that produce no concrete legal results. We must not wait for the completion of general political strategies while the defense teams face limited deadlines and direct responsibility for preparing the appeal submissions. It must be understood that defending the innocence of the accused cannot be achieved solely through political statements, protests or historical assessments of the KLA war. It must be argued through the means of criminal law, international criminal law, compelling evidence and fair-trial standards. Therefore, at this moment, Kosovo must shift the focus of its efforts from political mobilization to legal and professional mobilization.
2. Urgent establishment of a state commission of legal experts
The first and most urgent measure the Republic of Kosovo must take is to establish a special commission of legal experts, with a clear mandate, professional composition and limited timeframe kohor.Ky The commission should be composed of judges and former judges with a proven track record, prosecutors, criminal defense lawyers, professors of criminal law and experts in international criminal law, who have the professional competence to critically analyze the judgment and the judicial proceedings. The commission should be professional, pluralistic, independent in its assessments and free from party influence and political calculations.
Its mandate should be specific:
* To conduct a comprehensive legal analysis of the first-instance judgment.
* To identify possible violations of substantive and procedural law.
* To analyze how the evidence was presented, assessed and interpreted.
* To examine whether individual criminal responsibility was proven to the required standard.
* To analyze the legal basis of claims of command responsibility and other forms of criminal responsibility.
* To identify contradictions between the evidence, testimony and findings of the trial panel.
* To examine the procedural possibilities for introducing additional evidence and hearing new witnesses on appeal.
* To prepare a comprehensive legal document that can be made available to the defense teams as supplementary expert analysis for preparing their appeals.
This document should be a Kosovo legal expert analysis, built on an examination of the evidence, applicable legislation, case law and international standards. Domestic legal expertise is particularly important because Kosovo experts have direct knowledge of the historical, institutional, political and legal context in which the KLA war took place. An essential condition is that the commission’s work proceed in parallel and in professional coordination with the defense teams, without waiting for its document to be completed. Individual appeal deadlines must be respected under all circumstances. The commission’s document should serve as supplementary material for the defense and not as a condition or obstacle to filing appeals on time. For this reason, I propose that the commission begin work immediately and complete its expert analysis by the end of November, in accordance with the specific procedural deadlines.
3. The fundamental directions of the legal defense at second instance
The appeal strategy should be assertive, systematic and evidence-based. It should not be limited to general objections to the judgment, but should challenge each count of the indictment and each legal conclusion of the trial panel individually.
The defense should focus on these fundamental issues:
First, the incorrect or incomplete determination of the facts.
It must be analyzed whether the trial panel properly assessed the evidence presented, whether it drew conclusions unsupported by sufficient evidence and whether it ignored evidence that could be decisive for the accused’s innocence. Each count of the indictment should be examined separately. For each allegation, the supporting facts, the facts that contradict it and the shortcomings in the trial panel’s reasoning should be identified.
Second, challenging individual criminal responsibility.
It must be argued that criminal responsibility is individual and cannot be based on political positions, public reputation, military functions or general assumptions about the influence of the accused. In particular, the legal elements of each form of criminal responsibility attributed to the accused must be examined, including individual responsibility, command responsibility and forms of joint responsibility, if these were applied in the judgment. It must be analyzed whether all the constituent elements of the criminal offenses were established and whether the legal and factual connection between the specific acts of each accused and the crimes for which they were convicted was proven.
Third, critical analysis of the evidence and the credibility of witnesses.
The defense must carefully analyze the credibility, consistency, coherence and compatibility of testimony with other material evidence. The origin of testimony, the circumstances in which it was obtained, the possibility of influence on witnesses, contradictions between their statements and any other factor that may affect the credibility of the evidence must be examined. No testimony should be accepted as indisputable merely because it was given by a particular witness. It must be assessed in the context of the body of evidence as a whole and in accordance with fair-trial standards.
Fourth, presenting the historical and legal context of the war in Kosovo.
The defense must document and argue the context of the Kosovo war, its liberation character and the circumstances of systematic repression perpetrated by the Serbian state apparatus against the Albanian population. It must be documented that the KLA was formed amid repression, the denial of fundamental rights and state violence, as an organization of resistance and protection of the population. This context is essential to understanding the motives, aims and nature of the war, but it must not be used as a substitute for analyzing individual criminal responsibility. The liberation character of the war does not automatically rule out responsibility for an individual offense, if that offense is proven under the law. What must be challenged with arguments and evidence is any attempt to equate the character of a liberation organization with the existence of a criminal policy or plan.
Fifth, analysis of the KLA’s organizational and command structure.
One of the most important legal issues is how the KLA’s organization, its command structure, actual authority and the relations between political and military structures have been interpreted. The defense should present historical, military and institutional documentation, as well as concrete testimony, to clarify the nature of the KLA’s organization, its degree of institutionalization, how its structures functioned and the actual limits of individuals’ authority. It is not enough either to make a general assertion that no command hierarchy existed or to assume that a particular position automatically implies effective control over every member or unit. The issue must be proven concretely and individually, according to the legal criteria for criminal responsibility.
Sixth, challenging the allegation that a criminal plan or purpose existed.
The defense must examine whether there was concrete evidence of the existence of any criminal policy, plan or joint criminal enterprise, whether its legal elements were established and whether each accused’s individual connection to the alleged acts was proven. If any individuals committed criminal acts during the war, this cannot automatically be transformed into the collective responsibility of an entire organization or the criminal responsibility of its leaders without proving the relevant legal elements.
4. A stronger evidence and witness strategy consistent with appeal procedure
One of the main lessons to be drawn from the first-instance proceedings is the need for a broader, more concrete and more diversified evidence strategy. The defense should not rely primarily on senior political witnesses or well-known international figures, who may testify about the historical and political context of the war but not necessarily about specific events, locations, chains of communication and individual actions. For this reason, a full inventory should be made of potential witnesses from Kosovo, including eyewitnesses, former KLA members, institutional representatives, people with direct knowledge of specific events and experts in relevant fields. The defense should seek to build a strong evidentiary foundation that will enable it to specifically challenge the allegations in the indictment and the findings of the judgment. However, we must bear in mind an essential procedural distinction: an appeal is not an automatic retrial of the first-instance proceedings, nor is it an unlimited opportunity to present all evidence afresh. Therefore, the defense teams must carefully analyze the relevant provisions of the Law on the Specialist Chambers and the Rules of Procedure and Evidence, in order to identify the specific grounds on which admission of additional evidence, the hearing of new witnesses or the holding of supplementary hearings may be requested.
In this regard, the following should be argued in particular:
* Why the proposed evidence is relevant and material to the decision.
* Why it was not presented at first instance, where this is legally relevant.
* What impact it may have on the factual and legal findings of the judgment.
* Which conclusions of the trial panel might change if the evidence is admitted.
* Why hearing the specific witness is necessary to clarify a decisive issue.
If the procedural requirements are met, the defense should request the admission of additional evidence, the hearing of witnesses and, where necessary, the holding of relevant hearings. The possibility of remitting the case for retrial should also be examined, if the established violations and procedural provisions make this remedy necessary. The aim is not simply to increase the number of witnesses. The aim is for each testimony and each item of evidence to have concrete legal significance and contribute to refuting a specific finding in the judgment.
5. Transparency and international monitoring of the Specialist Chambers
Another important dimension is the need for transparency and independent monitoring of compliance with international fair-trial standards. The Republic of Kosovo should approach the donor states of the Specialist Chambers, requesting that they support the engagement of prestigious international organizations to monitor the judicial process and respect for human rights.
This monitoring should include, in particular:
* Compliance with the European Convention on Human Rights.
* Respect for the presumption of innocence.
* Equality of arms between the prosecution and the defense.
* Respect for the right to an effective defense.
* Impartial presentation and assessment of evidence.
* Respect for the principle of a fair trial within a reasonable time.
* Institutional transparency and accountability for how the court operates.
In this context, the assessments and concerns of international professional organizations, including the Bar Council of England and Wales, should also be taken seriously, and their specific recommendations and findings analyzed. Monitoring must not interfere with judicial independence or constitute an attempt to influence judges’ decision-making. It should serve to ensure compliance with fair-trial standards and increase confidence in the judicial process.
6. Diplomatic and institutional engagement by the Republic of Kosovo
At this stage, coordinated engagement by the highest state institutions is required. The President of the Republic of Kosovo, the Prime Minister and the Minister of Foreign Affairs must take urgent steps to communicate with the donor states of the Specialist Chambers and with friendly states that have supported Kosovo’s independence. This communication should take place through official letters, diplomatic meetings and direct contacts with representatives of these states. These communications should present the legitimate concerns of Kosovo’s institutions and citizens about the judicial process, compliance with international standards and the legal issues arising from the first-instance judgment.
In particular, the following should be requested:
1. Support for independent international monitoring of respect for human rights.
2. Greater transparency in the operation of the Specialist Chambers.
3. Engagement of prestigious organizations to assess fair-trial standards.
4. Support for independent international legal expertise.
5. Full respect for procedural guarantees and the rights of the defense.
Kosovo must act as a serious state, with legal arguments and institutional responsibility, avoiding any action that could be interpreted as political pressure on the court.
7. Learning from the Croatian experience: legal analysis of the Gotovina and Markač case
In preparing the new strategy, Croatia’s experience in judicial proceedings related to its war and the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia should be analyzed in particular. Especially important is the case of Croatian generals Ante Gotovina and Mladen Markač, who were convicted at first instance, but on November 16, 2012, the Tribunal’s Appeals Chamber acquitted them of the respective charges and overturned their first-instance convictions. This case should be studied not only as a historical and political experience, but above all as an important precedent for analyzing standards of evidence assessment and criminal responsibility.
In particular, Kosovo experts should analyze:
1.Si how the first-instance factual findings were challenged.
2. How the evidence supporting the conclusion that a joint criminal plan existed was treated.
3. What significance the standard of evidence assessment assumed at the appeal stage.
4. How the connection between individual acts and criminal responsibility was analyzed.
5. What legal reasons led to the convictions being overturned.
6. What lessons this experience offers for the appeal strategy in the case of the KLA leaders.
This study should be concrete and based on the text of the first-instance judgment and the Tribunal’s appeal judgment, not on general political interpretations. The Croatian experience should not be copied mechanically, because each proceeding has its own factual and legal specifics. Nevertheless, it demonstrates that an in-depth professional analysis of the evidence and judicial reasoning can be decisive in appeal proceedings. The main lesson is that a strong defense is built not only with political statements and historical arguments, but with in-depth legal expertise, reliable documentation and a systematic challenge to every contested item of evidence and finding.
8. Kosovo has no time to waste
The appeal process in the Specialist Chambers requires a new, urgent and organized approach. This is not the time for party clashes, routine political statements or initiatives that produce no concrete results. This is the time for legal expertise, for mobilizing Kosovo’s best professional capabilities and for coordinated institutional engagement. The Republic of Kosovo must understand that defending the KLA leaders at this stage cannot remain solely the responsibility of individual lawyers’ teams. The state must create the conditions for providing domestic expertise, historical and institutional documentation, and legal analyses that can assist the defense teams, without compromising their professional autonomy or the court’s independence.
In this regard, I propose that the following actions be taken immediately:
1. Establish a state commission of legal experts.
2. Prepare, by the end of November, a comprehensive document on possible substantive and procedural violations identified in the first-instance proceedings.
3. Make this document available to the defense teams as supplementary legal expertise.
4. Identify witnesses and additional evidence that may be admitted under the rules of appeal procedure.
5. Engage international experts to analyze the most complex legal issues.
6. Request independent international monitoring of compliance with fair-trial standards.
7. Activate Kosovo’s diplomacy in relation to donor states and Kosovo’s friendly states.
8. Conduct a specialized study of the experience of the Gotovina and Markač case, with the aim of identifying legal arguments and standards that may be relevant to the current proceedings.
One issue must be clear: the work of the state commission must neither wait nor delay the work of the defense teams. Both processes must proceed in parallel, because compliance with procedural deadlines is a fundamental condition for the effectiveness of any appeal strategy. We must be aware that we face a difficult, complex battle with significant legal, historical and state-related consequences. This is why seriousness, professionalism, institutional unity and determination are required. The KLA war must be defended through historical truth, while the innocence of the accused must be argued through evidence and the standards of criminal law.
Now is not the time for a political battle. It is time for an organized, assertive and professional legal battle. Kosovo must act immediately, because every day lost may be a lost opportunity to build a stronger defense. We have no time to waste. Now is the time for state, professional and legal action.

















