Ekonomia Online
LATEST

The Mirror We Refuse to See Ourselves In

The Mirror We Refuse to See Ourselves In

.

Increasingly, derogatory comments, racial prejudice and expressions of hostility toward foreign workers arriving from Asian countries are appearing on Albanian social media. Our people have a fitting saying: “If you can’t do anything to the donkey, you hit the saddle.” It describes someone who, unable or lacking the courage to confront the real person responsible, takes out their anger on someone weaker. This proverb aptly describes the way some Albanians are reacting to the arrival of foreign workers, instead of speaking out against the misgovernment that is driving their fellow citizens to emigrate.

The main causes of depopulation lie in state capture, legal insecurity, a lack of opportunities for young people, underdeveloped infrastructure, poor public services and other problems linked to the misgovernment of the country. Instead of directing our anger at those responsible for this situation, we take issue with Indians, Filipinos and other foreigners who have come here to earn a living. Thus, part of the public debate confuses cause and effect, claiming that foreigners are depopulating Albania. We focus on the symptoms of depopulation, even though the source of the disease has a clear political address. This behavior also reveals a troubling historical and moral amnesia. For more than three decades, Albanians have sought better opportunities in Europe and beyond. We have experienced discrimination, prejudice and contempt because of our nationality. We have rightly demanded that our compatriots be treated with dignity and valued for their work. In Italy and Greece, particularly during the 1990s, Albanian emigrants faced stereotypes that portrayed them as a threat to security, the economy and social order.

Italy and Greece, too, had a long history of mass emigration at the time. Millions of their citizens had sought a better life in America, Australia, Germany and other countries, just like our compatriots. Nevertheless, this historical experience did not prevent some parts of these societies from showing hostility toward newcomers. Today, unfortunately, we are seeing signs of a similar mindset in Albania. According to the regional SecuriMeter 2025 survey, organized by the Regional Cooperation Council, 51% of respondents in Albania see immigration as a source of social tensions and conflicts, demonstrating how widespread negative perceptions of immigrants are.

But before legitimizing the paranoia of a “silent invasion,” it is enough to confront the stubborn facts of the statistical reality. According to Eurostat, at the end of 2025, around 875,000 Albanian citizens held residence permits in the European Union, not counting the hundreds of thousands more who have acquired citizenship in host countries over the years. On the other hand, according to INSTAT, the total number of foreign citizens with residence permits in Albania is around 32,000, a figure that includes students, entrepreneurs, managers and missionaries, not just manual laborers. Even more telling is the selectivity of this public alarm. More than half of the foreigners legally residing in Albania (52.9%) come from the European continent, led by citizens from Kosovo (19.05%) and Italy (12.6%), while those from Asian countries make up less than a third (30.8%), notably India at 9% and the Philippines at 7.5%. If collective concern were genuinely about demographic pressure or the capacity of the domestic market, it would also encompass the majority of foreign residents. The fact that social media hysteria and everyday contempt target Asians above all shows that racial prejudice fuels part of this debate. It is no coincidence, then, that the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance of the Council of Europe, in its June 2026 report, raised concerns about the spread of racist hate speech in Albania, especially online, where immigrants are among the groups affected.

This situation also fuels imported conspiracy theories about a deliberate plan for the “replacement of the population.” No conspiracy is needed to explain a phenomenon occurring around the world. Albanians are emigrating en masse to Italy, while Italians themselves continue to leave for more developed economies, such as Switzerland. Around 1.15 million Italian citizens have emigrated abroad over the past decade. Meanwhile, workers from India, the Philippines and other Asian countries come to Albania, where they hope to find better economic opportunities. The researcher Hein de Haas explains this phenomenon through the “aspirations and capabilities model” of migration, according to which people migrate when they want a better life and have a real opportunity to move. Differences in wages, living conditions and employment prospects influence the direction of these movements. Just as an Albanian leaves for the West to earn a higher income and escape insecurity, a citizen from Asia may see Albania as a place where their work is better paid than in their homeland. These movements do not prove any secret plan to replace the population, but reflect the inequalities and differing opportunities offered by the international economy.

Of course, the arrival of foreign workers calls for responsible labor-market policies. The state must guarantee decent wages, rigorous inspections to curb the exploitation of foreigners through grueling hours, and penalties for employers who violate labor laws or use foreign workers to artificially lower employment standards. Local businesses, often accustomed to the convenient model of cheap labor, must invest in productivity and improve wages and working conditions.

At the same time, foreign workers are filling part of the gap left in the labor market by Albanian emigration, accepting jobs with wages and conditions that many Albanians are no longer willing to accept. Without these workers, many businesses would risk closing for lack of staff. They have come to an economy that needs their labor, while some of its citizens have chosen to seek better opportunities abroad. So we should not forget that a Filipina working in a hotel in Tirana has made no decisions about Albania’s fate. She has not drawn up economic policies, destroyed meritocracy, run the education and healthcare systems, or bears responsibility for the lack of prospects that has driven hundreds of thousands of Albanians to emigrate. Political responsibility lies with those who have governed the country, who have had the power, budget and tools to change the situation. It is much easier to insult an Indian delivering food in the rain, who often does not even know the language well enough to defend himself, than to hold the prime minister, ministers, powerful politicians and oligarchs who have influenced decision-making to account. Blaming immigrants for depopulation means giving an alibi to precisely those who must answer for Albania’s emptying out. From the boats crossing the Strait of Otranto in the 1990s to today’s delivery scooters, the story is essentially the same: people leaving their homeland to secure a better life for themselves and their families. The way we treat newcomers today is a mirror in which we can see how much we have learned from our own history of emigration. We cannot demand humanity and equal integration for Albanians in Munich, London and Rome while showing brutality and indifference toward immigrants in the middle of Tirana. If we are angry about the state of the country, we must have the courage to direct that anger at those who hold power and bear responsibility for it. Confronting the powerful requires courage and moral integrity, while venting on the weaker is simply cowardice. A nation that has suffered such deep humiliation on foreign soil has no excuse for turning itself into a persecutor of newcomers.

Related