The judgment of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers in the case against Hashim Thaçi, Kadri Veseli, Rexhep Selimi and Jakup Krasniqi constitutes a development of particular importance for the legal order, institutional life and historical memory of the Republic of Kosovo. The judgment of 16 September 2026 found the accused guilty of four counts of war crimes and imposed individual sentences on them. As a first-instance judgment, it is subject to the legal remedies provided for under the legal framework of the Specialist Chambers and, consequently, the case remains subject to further judicial review.
The Flawed Narrative in Judge Charles Smith’s Reasoning

The judgment of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers in the case against Hashim Thaçi, Kadri Veseli, Rexhep Selimi and Jakup Krasniqi constitutes a development of particular importance for the legal order, institutional life and historical memory of the Republic of Kosovo. The judgment of 16 September 2026 found the accused guilty of four counts of war crimes and imposed individual sentences on them. As a first-instance judgment, it is subject to the legal remedies provided for under the legal framework of the Specialist Chambers and, consequently, the case remains subject to further judicial review.
After challenging the characterization, in our view unjustified, of “joint criminal enterprise” in the previous article, today the fourth article in the series will focus on another aspect of this criticism: the tendency to alter the historical narrative of the Kosovo Liberation Army’s war and the failure to clearly distinguish between the genocide and crimes committed by Serbian forces against the Albanian population, and the KLA’s liberation and defensive war. Judge Charles L. Smith III’s reasoning, as presiding judge of the Trial Panel, when delivering the judgment against the KLA leaders, raises serious concern about how the political and historical context of the Kosovo war has been presented.
It is particularly troubling that Judge Smith himself stated in his address “that he was not prejudging the question of whether the war for Kosovo’s independence was lawful or not.” This is an important statement. But it is precisely for this reason that the question arises: if the lawfulness of the war for independence was not the subject of his assessment, why was the historical context that gave rise to that war, and its political and liberation purpose, not presented with due weight in his public address?
This question becomes even more significant when we recall that, just a few hundred metres from where this address was delivered, the International Court of Justice had confirmed that Kosovo’s Declaration of Independence of 17 February 2008 had not violated international law. Thus, Kosovo’s international legal history cannot be separated from the context of the war, liberation and the process that led to independence.
Judge Smith’s exposition does not sufficiently address the repression of Kosovo Albanians by the Milošević regime, the denial of their political and constitutional rights, or the violence that preceded and accompanied the war. It also lacks an adequate treatment of the genocide, violence and crimes committed by Serbian forces against the Albanian civilian population. These are not secondary circumstances, but fundamental elements for understanding why and under what circumstances the Kosovo war took place.
The KLA did not emerge in a vacuum. It arose amid prolonged repression and the denial of the fundamental rights of Kosovo Albanians. The KLA was an Albanian patriotic guerrilla force that waged a defensive and liberation war, confronting the Serbian state, police and military apparatus and protecting the Albanian population from genocide, violence and repression. Its political goal was the liberation of Kosovo and the fulfilment of its aspiration for freedom and independence.
It is precisely for this reason that it is problematic that the cause of the war, the preceding repression, the violence against the Albanian population, its political character and the KLA’s role in the struggle to liberate Kosovo did not receive their due place in Judge Charles L. Smith III’s address. A fundamental distinction must be made: individual criminal responsibility is one matter, while the historical description of the war is another. These two planes must not be confused, nor should one be used to diminish the other.
An approach focused primarily on crimes attributed to KLA members, without placing them within the historical framework of Serbian repression and the liberation war, can create a false historical narrative, especially for people who do not know Kosovo’s history in depth. If Serbian repression, violence against the Albanian population and the cause of the war are removed from the picture, the false impression may arise that the KLA was the primary source of violence and that the Kosovo war had no historical and politik.Ky cause. This would represent a serious reversal of the historical perspective on the Kosovo war.
To understand a war, it is not enough to say only what happened during it. It must also be explained why it began, what repression preceded it, against whom the violence was perpetrated, and what the political purpose was of the forces that took up arms. In this sense, the crimes committed by the Serbian state apparatus against the Albanian population cannot be equated in a single narrative with the KLA’s liberation and defensive war. Even if a criminal trial has a legally defined subject, the history of the war requires a distinction between repression and resistance, between state violence and a struggle for liberation. Moreover, those responsible for crimes committed by the Serbian state apparatus against the population of Kosovo were not the subject of this judicial process. This is a circumstance that must be taken into account when assessing the impact such a narrative may have on public perceptions of the history of the war.
Therefore, the criticism of Judge Charles L. Smith III’s address is not that a court should not address possible individual criminal responsibility. The criticism is that when a narrative about the Kosovo war is presented to the public, its fundamental political and historical context cannot be left in the shadows. The Kosovo war did not begin with the KLA, and the KLA was not its cause. It emerged in response to a long-standing genocidal and repressive policy and waged a war to liberate and defend Kosovo. For this reason, any attempt to separate the KLA from this context risks producing a distorted narrative of Kosovo’s history.
In this context, there is serious concern that certain interpretations of the historical context of the war, if detached from the full range of facts and developments that characterized Kosovo, may produce a reduced narrative of its history and create the conditions for a one-sided revision of the wartime period and the state-building process. Such a risk must be treated as a matter of general state and historical interest.
The history of Kosovo and the war of the Kosovo Liberation Army must be studied in their entirety: in relation to systematic repression, Serbia’s genocide against the Albanian population, the liberation war, grave human rights violations, international intervention, international administration, and the legal and political process that led to the creation and consolidation of the institutions of the Republic of Kosovo. No dimension of this history can be artificially separated from the whole.
This flawed approach to the Kosovo war must be countered through a broad mobilization of Albanian and international academic expertise. The Academy of Sciences and Arts of Kosovo, universities and research institutes should contribute, in accordance with their competences and academic autonomy, to the study of historical, legal and documentary sources related to the Kosovo war, creating a strong scientific basis for understanding the historical context in which the events took place.
Justice requires an assessment of the facts and possible individual responsibility; history requires its entirety. Neither should be separated from its context.

















