Ekonomia Online
LATEST

The state killed Arlinda!

The state killed Arlinda!

Arlinda Zekaj did not need statements and condolences after her death. She needed protection while she was alive. She did not need the institutions to remember her after she was killed, but to listen when she asked them for help. She had warned the state. The state must explain why it failed to save her. Arlinda Zekaj had warned […]

Arlinda Zekaj did not need statements and condolences after her death. She needed protection while she was alive. She did not need the institutions to remember her after she was killed, but to listen when she asked them for help. She had warned the state. The state must explain why it failed to save her.

Arlinda Zekaj had warned of her own death. Not in a private conversation, not through a message that might get lost on someone’s phone, but in letters addressed to the Prosecutor’s Office in Peja. She had asked for help and raised concerns so that action would be taken before it was too late. On October 25, she was killed. Just three days after her warning.

There are not many ways to describe this tragedy. A woman asked the state for protection and did not receive it in time. A woman tried to make it clear to the institutions that her life was in danger, but her warning was not enough to save her. A woman who should have been protected ended up dead. And society is once again facing the same question it has asked after dozens of similar cases: how much longer?

According to suspicions made public, Arlinda was killed by her brother-in-law. The perpetrator must answer before the law for this crime. But it would be unacceptable for the investigation to end with only the man suspected of taking her life. Because, alongside the perpetrator’s criminal responsibility, there is another, equally important question: could this murder have been prevented if the institutions had taken seriously the danger Arlinda had warned them about?

This question is not for political consumption. Nor is it intended to appease public anger, which after every murder of a woman is filled with statements, reactions and promises. It is a question about the state’s responsibility for the lives of its citizens. In this case, the answer must come from the documents, the actions of officials and an independent investigation—not from press conferences or empty statements.

Arlinda had requested urgent intervention and raised concerns about how the institutions were handling her case. On Sunday, October 25, she again reported domestic violence. Her ex-husband was arrested, while she was taken home under police escort. A little later, she was found dead. This is one of the most shocking details of this event: a woman who had asked for protection ended up dead, even though the institutions had been made aware of the danger.

It is not enough to say that the police took her home “of her own free will.” Nor is it enough to say that a procedure was followed according to a particular interpretation of the rules. The institutions’ duty is not simply to carry out a few formal acts, fill in forms and register complaints. Their duty is to understand the danger, assess the circumstances and take measures that protect life. When there is a serious warning, responsibility does not end with the question of whether or not the victim requested a particular measure. The institutions must do everything the law allows to prevent tragedy.

This is precisely where the failure that must be investigated begins. What happened to Arlinda’s letter? Who reviewed it? What measures were taken after it was received? Was the threat to her life genuinely assessed? Was the court decision she had sought intervention over enforced? Did the police, the prosecution and the Center for Social Work coordinate? And, above all, who decided that she could be returned to a situation where, just a little later, she was killed?

These are not questions that can be closed with an administrative report drawn up to shield the institution from criticism. The answers must be public, supported by facts and accompanied by concrete consequences if officials are found to have neglected their duties. People cannot be asked to trust in justice when justice fails to protect a woman who turns to it for help.

If it is established that negligence, inaction or a breach of officials’ legal obligations contributed to the failure to prevent this murder, responsibility must be both individual and institutional. Resignations cannot replace an investigation, but neither can an investigation be used as an excuse to avoid taking responsibility. There must be professional, disciplinary and criminal consequences. Otherwise, this will be just another case in which the institutions promise to learn lessons, only to carry on as if nothing had happened.

* * *

Political responsibility must also be addressed here. The state is not an abstract notion, nor a building without a name or address. It consists of institutions and is run by people with specific duties. Governments may adopt strategies against domestic violence, ministries may draw up action plans, and officials may hold press conferences to show how much is being done. But if a woman warns that she may be killed and is found dead three days later, then all these documents and promises must be called into question.

This is not the first time Kosovo has faced the murder of women. Whenever a crime of this kind occurs, the same sentences are heard: there will be an investigation, there will be accountability, measures will be taken. Then the days pass, public attention shifts elsewhere and the victims’ families are left with their grief. Meanwhile, women experiencing violence continue to ask themselves whether it is worth seeking help, whether they will be heard and whether the institutions will be there when they need them most.

This is the greatest harm such a failure causes: not only the loss of a life, but also the destruction of trust that the state can protect you. When a woman asks for help and ends up dead, the message sent to other women is horrific. Without words, they are told that even a warning may not be enough.

Therefore, Arlinda’s murder must not be treated only as a crime committed by an individual. It must also be investigated as evidence of the failure of the system that was supposed to protect her. The institutions knew of the danger and did not take the necessary measures; therefore, the state bears responsibility for the death it failed to prevent.

Arlinda did not need statements and condolences after her death. She needed protection while she was alive. She did not need the institutions to remember her after she was killed, but to listen when she asked them for help. She had warned the state. The state must explain why it failed to save her.

If this murder, too, ends without real accountability, then it will not be just another failure. It will be proof that in this country, a woman’s life can be considered less important than bureaucracy, indifference and the institutions’ fear of confronting their own mistakes.

And then, the question will no longer be only who killed Arlinda. It will be how many more times the state will allow women to die, even though they have warned that they are in danger.

Related