Ekonomia Online
LATEST

Violence That Produces Only Spectators and a Spectacle with Hired Actors

Violence That Produces Only Spectators and a Spectacle with Hired Actors

Beyond the negative emotions stirred by violence on the streets of Tirana and the police response, the truth is that, after a week, the protests in Tirana have divided the sides into spectators rather than participants. In a way, after seven days of street violence, Albanian society has not become part of the protests, but part of the debate […]

Beyond the negative emotions stirred by violence on the streets of Tirana and the police response, the truth is that, after a week, the protests in Tirana have divided the sides into spectators rather than participants.

In a way, after seven days of street violence, Albanian society has not become part of the protests, but part of the debate about violence at protests.

In other words, the protests have remained the preserve of a violent, well-trained group whose members, in many cases, carry out combat operations far more professionally than the police. They know how to throw Molotov cocktails, know how to use pyrotechnic weapons, have athletic, well-prepared physiques, and are all masked.

If you watch the videos posted by the young people themselves who support the protest, they appear organized as they enter the crowd of protesters, are greeted with applause—even as heroes—and, after getting dressed and armed, set off as if going to war.

This is an indication that the protest is not a spontaneous eruption of violence against Tirana, but prepared and trained violence.

Beyond the professional skill the police are showing in confronting the violence, the other side of the matter—the police intelligence work needed to track and uncover who these trained forces are, who have no connection to the students they claim to represent on the front line against the police—is a failure. The detained protesters, mostly from the North and Kosovo, talk about payments, hotels where they stay that are also paid for, trips from Europe to Albania paid for, and so on. There is no problem with them being paid, but the country’s security institutions have a duty to uncover the funders and trainers of this violent network, because we are not talking about a spontaneous protest, but a spectacle with hired actors.

Then there are those moving scenes involving some excessive use of force by the police or some act of heroism by protesters, who assault isolated, unprofessional police officers; these are Instagram material. The truth is that the protest is a ritual that begins at the Ministry of Education, where the “masked men” arrive, and then marches toward the Prime Minister’s Office, where they wage an hour-long battle. Then they disperse through the streets of Tirana to rob a shop or burn a business from the list publicly announced by the organizers.

Secondly, we have a protest that reveals clear signs of political Islam mixing in. It cannot dominate the protest, but it sullies it. The protest’s legitimacy stems from the fact that it is the revolt of a generation of young people who have been left in ghettos and do not feel equal in a society that has left them on the margins. But the fact that neighborhood imams recruit teenagers; that women wearing headscarves, with sticks in their hands, attack police officers; or, worse still, that protesters are fixated on smashing the Vatican Embassy or the symbols of Gjergj Fishta in Lezhë and Skanderbeg in Skanderbeg Square, clearly shows that someone is seeking to gain political capital as a jihadist movement as well.

It is not that our society is influenced by them, but it is frightened. For example, I have not seen a single Albanian intellectual condemn the attack on Gjergj Fishta’s Lahuta e Malcis, and you would think that the most violent leaders of the protest are from Lekbibaj, the Catholic enclave of the Highlands of Tropoja. Even that female MP, who won’t let you speak even in standard Albanian, has fallen silent after witnessing the assault on the father of Gheg Albanian, Gjergj Fishta.

This shows that those behind these gestures wield the power of fear over the protesters and society.

Finally, as if all this were not enough, there has also been an increase in the irritating voices from Kosovo, policing Albania and events here and taking sides in a story that is not theirs. Kosovo’s top leaders have become involved in a hysterical campaign against the Albanian police, hoping to bring down Edi Rama.

Edi Rama may be brought down for a thousand reasons in Albania, but not for a hundred thousand reasons coming from Kosovo. And especially not by Albin Kurti. Albulena Haxhiu, the Speaker of Kosovo’s Assembly, speaks as if she were a Taliban spokesperson and gives directives on how the government should surrender in the face of violence, as though this were Albulena’s Battle, in which the Turks must defeat Skanderbeg. The opposite happened, and damn it, that did not go unnamed.

Albin Kurti’s closest advisers, his official and unofficial spokespeople, have made grave statements, the likes of which even the protest leaders do not make. I know many people in Albania are outraged by this, but I, who know both sides a little better, tell them to calm down.

If there is one thing working in Edi Rama’s favor in this story, equally justified and undeserved, it is the attack coming from Albin Kurti. It wins him more support in Albania, precisely because of the idea that Albin Kurti thinks he can dictate to Albania. It is more or less like the story of 2021, when he came as a triumphant figure to vote and left that evening with 130 votes.

So forgive Albin Kurti’s Kosovars for this madness; it does us no harm. It simply shows what hands Kosovo has fallen into. The man who keeps Kosovo importing flour and food from Serbia has only one export commodity: demonstrators for Albania and thinkers like Putin’s, who rub their hands at the fires in Tirana. All right, let’s sit them down as negotiators too, if we get to that day. But they should stop ringing in our ears.

The protest is neither popular nor massive, has not plunged Albania into violence, and has no political objective. So far, the objective is two hours of violence on the boulevard, a spectacle, and then a return home and an online battle. They are doing very well there. They have won the battle. But nothing more.

The problem is that protests like these should generate political energy and be channeled into elections and solutions that serve Albania. So far, they serve only those who have trained them and are successfully pitting them against the police. Good luck in life to them, and good luck on the job to the police officers.

Related