Ekonomia Online
LATEST

Journalism in Times of Crisis: Truth, Ethics Over Sensationalism, and Journalists’ Professional Responsibility in Sensitive Situations

Journalism in Times of Crisis: Truth, Ethics Over Sensationalism, and Journalists’ Professional Responsibility in Sensitive Situations

Legal knowledge, rigorous fact-checking, adherence to professional ethics, protection of victims, and control of emotions are among the fundamental pillars of professional reporting on crime and in highly sensitive situations. Ethics is the compass that should guide journalists under all circumstances, defining the boundaries between the public interest and violations of […]

Legal knowledge, rigorous fact-checking, adherence to professional ethics, protection of victims, and control of emotions are among the fundamental pillars of professional reporting on crime and in highly sensitive situations. Ethics is the compass that should guide journalists under all circumstances, defining the boundaries between the public interest and violations of human dignity, between informing and sensationalism, and between the right to know and the responsibility not to cause harm. Professional journalism does not fuel fear, but informs society; it does not pass judgment, but seeks and presents facts; it does not serve noise, but the truth. Because journalism without ethics loses credibility, while journalism without verification puts the truth itself at risk.

“When the phone rings in the middle of the night, a firefighter only has to put on his trousers and put out the flames. But a journalist has to tell a million people who struck the match and why.” – David Randall

This quote by British journalist and author David Randall aptly sums up the complexity of the journalism profession. Unlike many other professions, journalism does not end with establishing that an event has taken place. It seeks to uncover the circumstances, verify the facts, identify sources, analyze responsibilities and, above all, provide the public with as accurate a picture as possible of what happened.

This responsibility becomes even greater when journalists are confronted with criminal incidents, human tragedies, murders, violence, fatal accidents, human trafficking, corruption, abuse, or other situations of high social sensitivity.

Reporting on a press conference, an institutional event, or a political statement is a process with its own professional specifics. But reporting from a crime scene, gathering information under tense circumstances, communicating with witnesses, institutions and victims’ family members, while maintaining accuracy, impartiality and composure, is an entirely different challenge.

This is precisely where the difference lies between a journalist who merely transmits information and one who deeply understands the responsibility of the profession.

Crisis as a true test of journalistic professionalism?

In times of crisis, citizens seek answers. They want to know what happened, who is involved, what the consequences are and what the relevant institutions are doing.

In these circumstances, the media and journalists play an exceptionally important role in informing the public, ensuring institutional transparency and promoting accountability.

However, precisely at the moments when the public demands immediate information, journalists must show that they are not slaves to time pressure, media competition or click counts.

Professional journalism is not a race to be first to publish a photograph, a name, a claim or unconfirmed information. It is not a race for shocking headlines and interpretations unsupported by facts.

It is a public responsibility.

Journalists must be physically, psychologically, emotionally and intellectually prepared. They must be vigilant, persistent, present in the field, careful in their communications and able to cope with situations that are often unpredictable.

Professional preparation does not mean only knowing interviewing techniques or how to write a news story. It also includes general knowledge, legal knowledge, media literacy, analytical skills and emotional control.

Crime reporting: where legal knowledge becomes a professional necessity?

Reporting on murders, aggravated murders, assaults, domestic violence, sexual assaults, robberies, trafficking, corruption and other forms of criminality requires deeper knowledge than that offered by ordinary news journalism.

Journalists must know the differences between a suspect, a detained person, an arrested person, an accused person and a convicted person. These are not synonyms and cannot be used carelessly just to make a headline more appealing.

A suspect is not a convicted person. An indictment is not a judgment. An arrest does not prove guilt, and a statement given to the police does not necessarily constitute an indisputable conclusion of criminal proceedings.

Journalists who do not understand these distinctions risk producing misinformation, harming individuals’ reputations and creating false perceptions among the public.

Therefore, knowledge of legal terminology should not be considered a privilege reserved for journalists who cover the courts. It should be part of the basic preparation of every journalist reporting on criminal matters.

The presumption of innocence – a principle that must not be negotiated?

One of the most common mistakes in crime reporting is prematurely declaring guilt through headlines, wording and journalists’ interpretations.

Terms such as “murderer,” “rapist,” “criminal” or “thief,” when there is no final court ruling establishing the person’s guilt, may constitute a serious breach of professional and ethical standards.

Journalists are not prosecutors, judges or investigative bodies. They have the right and duty to inform, investigate, seek accountability and analyze institutional actions, but they cannot take on the role of the justice system.

This does not mean journalists should be passive or limit themselves to official statements. On the contrary, they must be persistent in seeking facts, but always within the bounds of the law, ethics and the public interest.

Editorial independence does not preclude legal and ethical responsibility.

Domestic violence and violence against women: sensitivity must not turn into sensationalism?

Reporting on domestic violence, and especially violence against women, is one of the most sensitive areas of journalism.

In many cases, the media publish unnecessary details about the victim, her family relationships, private life, personal communications and the circumstances of the incident. Sometimes these details have no genuine informational value, but are published to increase readers’ interest.

This approach can cause repeated victimization, undermine the victim’s dignity and expose family members to public pressure.

Journalists must distinguish between what is interesting to the public and what is genuinely in the public interest.

Not every piece of information obtained should be published. Not every detail found in an investigative file is valuable to readers.

Particular care should be taken with statements by those involved, especially in the initial stages of an investigation. They may change, be clarified or be challenged during subsequent proceedings.

Journalists must verify claims through independent sources, documents and competent institutions, and must not treat any single statement as the final truth.

Protecting victims is not an obstacle to informing the public. It is part of responsible journalism.

The first 12 hours: when haste can cause professional harm?

One of the problems I have noticed in online media reporting is the rush to publish information immediately after a criminal incident occurs.

The pressure to be first, get more reads and keep up with the competition often pushes newsrooms to publish details that have not been sufficiently verified.

The first hours of an investigation are particularly sensitive. Information may be partial, witness accounts may be contradictory and the circumstances of the incident may still be unclear.

An initial statement may change. A claim may prove inaccurate. A person initially mentioned as being involved may have no responsibility for the incident at all.

This is why journalists must exercise restraint and not confuse speed with professionalism.

Not every piece of information needs to be published within the minute. It is far more important that published information be accurate.

In my professional experience, investigating and verifying every detail before publication are among the most important guarantees of credible journalism.

Sources, documents and verification: don’t confuse credibility with authority?

Journalists must build professional relationships with the police, prosecution, courts, institutions and other sources of information.

But communication with an official should not automatically be considered a complete guarantee that every piece of information is true.

Official sources, too, must be subject to verification standards.

Signed documents, institutional decisions, procedural acts and official statements can be particularly important sources, but journalists must understand their content, context and limitations.

A document may confirm that a procedure has begun, but not necessarily that the claims presented in it have been proven.

A police statement may confirm an arrest, but not the person’s guilt.

Therefore, journalists must compare sources, seek independent confirmation and avoid publishing claims as established facts.

There is an American saying that sums up this principle quite well: “Even when your mother tells you she loves you, verify it.”

In journalism, trust is important, but verification is essential.

Victims, minors and family tragedies: human dignity over commercial interest?

One of the most difficult tests for a journalist is reporting on deaths, suicides, murders of women, sexual assaults, fatal accidents and tragedies involving children.

In these cases, journalists must not forget that behind a news story there is a family, a human story and people dealing with extraordinary pain.

Publishing photographs of victims, identifying them unnecessarily, interviewing family members while they are in shock and describing the manner of death in detail can have serious consequences.

Reporting on suicides, for example, requires avoiding details about methods, locations and elements that could encourage imitation of such acts.

When minors are involved in an incident, protecting their identity and best interests must be a priority.

Journalists must understand that not everything that can be photographed, recorded or uncovered should be made public.

Professional ethics begin precisely where journalists are able to forgo information or a photograph that does not serve the public interest.

Journalists are not investigators, but should they have an investigative mindset?

I have often stressed that journalists should be a kind of investigator in the professional sense of the word, but this does not mean they should assume the powers of the police or prosecution.

Journalists must investigate, compare statements, seek documents, analyze contradictions, identify inconsistencies and seek answers from institutions.

They must be able to distinguish a claim from a fact, an indication from evidence, and a suspicion from a legal conclusion.

An investigative mindset is one of the most important qualities of a professional journalist.

Nevertheless, journalists must not interfere with evidence, obstruct investigative actions, reveal the identities of protected witnesses without cause or publish information that could endanger the safety of those involved.

Their task is to inform and seek accountability, not to obstruct justice.

Emotions and biases: the weakness that can harm journalism?

We cannot be journalists without feelings when reporting on murders, sexual assaults, injuries, accidents, trafficking, corruption or family tragedies.

Journalists are human and experience emotions. They may be shaken by a crime scene, moved by a victim’s account or feel outrage in the face of injustice.

But there is a fundamental difference between human empathy and professional bias.

Emotions must not turn into journalistic conclusions. Personal outrage cannot replace evidence. Sympathy for one side cannot influence the presentation of facts.

Journalists must retain the ability to report with dignity, even when a subject is emotionally difficult.

This does not require a lack of feeling, but self-control, maturity and professional integrity.

Online media and the click trap: speed is not a virtue if it harms the truth?

Online and television media operate in an environment where time has taken on extraordinary importance.

The public wants real-time news, while newsrooms face pressure from competition and audience demands.

However, the problem arises when speed becomes the main criterion for success and a bombastic headline is valued more than verified content.

Headlines that declare people guilty, create panic, dramatize unclear situations or use exaggerated terms do not help inform the public.

A headline should be engaging, but first and foremost it must be accurate.

A news story can be exclusive without being sensational. It can be powerful without being shocking. It can attract attention without violating anyone’s dignity.

The media must understand that credibility is not built with a single click, but with years of responsible work.

Journalist safety in the field: physical, psychological and professional preparation?

Reporting from conflict zones, protests, riots, natural disasters, crime scenes and dangerous situations requires special preparation.

Journalists must know how to act in an unsafe environment, assess risks, communicate with their team and protect themselves and their sources.

Physical preparation is important, but it is not enough. Psychological preparation, knowledge of safety protocols, the ability to remain calm and make quick decisions without risking one’s life are equally important.

Journalists should not prove their professionalism by exposing themselves to unnecessary danger.

No photograph, recording or exclusive is worth more than a journalist’s life and safety.

Legal knowledge and ethics – an essential part of a journalist’s training?

Contemporary journalism requires more than the ability to write a good news story.

It requires knowledge of laws, procedures, institutions and legal terminology.

Journalists reporting on the courts must understand how the judicial system works and the roles of the prosecutor, defense lawyer, trial panel, Court of Appeals, Supreme Court and Constitutional Court.

They must know what a criminal complaint, an indictment, a pretrial detention measure, a judgment and a final ruling represent.

They must also know the boundaries between the public interest, privacy, source protection and responsibility for publishing information.

This knowledge does not turn journalists into lawyers, but makes them better equipped to practice their profession accurately and responsibly.

Professional experience and my contribution to addressing reporting on sensitive situations?

All these issues are not merely theoretical assessments or general principles of journalism. They also stem from my professional experience, research, work in journalism and academic work.

To address these issues in greater depth, in 2023 I published my book entitled:

“The Media, Ethics, Reporting on Sensitive Situations, Investigations and Legal Concepts in Journalism”.

In this publication, I have addressed a wide range of topics related to professional, ethical and legal reporting.

I have analyzed reporting on murders, suicides, injuries, accidents, domestic violence, sexual assaults, sexual harassment, human trafficking, prostitution, corruption, bribery, thefts, robberies, war crimes, terrorism, genocide, kidnappings, hostage-taking, cybercrime and many other categories of criminal offenses.

I have devoted particular attention to reporting on minors, people with disabilities, people with mental health problems, victims of violence and families affected by tragedies.

An important part of the book addresses the relationships between the media, police, prosecution and courts, as well as the legal concepts journalists use in their daily work.

I have also covered investigative procedures, police actions, criminal complaints, autopsies, the filing of indictments, reporting from court hearings, the role of defense lawyers, trial panels, closing arguments and types of judgments.

Including these topics in a professional publication is intended to help journalists move beyond superficial reporting and develop a deeper understanding of the issues they cover.

Journalism requires continuous preparation. Legal, ethical and professional knowledge is not a luxury, but a necessity.

Does journalism need character, not just speed?

Finally, I want to emphasize that professional journalism is not measured only by the number of news stories published, the speed of reporting or the audience a media outlet reaches.

It is measured by the accuracy of information, the courage to seek the truth, the ability to protect the public interest and respect for human dignity.

Journalists must be courageous, but not reckless; critical, but not biased; persistent, but not intrusive; emotionally sensitive, but professionally impartial.

It is not always easy to report on a murder, a family tragedy, a case of violence or a serious crime. But it is precisely in these situations that a journalist’s level of preparation and integrity is revealed.

Journalism should not produce fear, panic and premature judgments. It should produce information, transparency, awareness and social responsibility.

At a time when information circulates at extraordinary speed and anyone can publish a claim in the digital space, professional journalists must remain a point of reference for verification, credibility and truth.

Because the public does not need a journalist who merely tells them what happened. It needs a journalist who helps them understand what happened, what is known, what is still unknown and who must be held accountable.

Truth must not become a victim of speed, ethics must not be held hostage to clicks, and journalism must not lose its mission in the face of sensationalism.

Investigate, verify and report – are detail and motive the essence of professional journalism?

My professional philosophy of journalism is consistently based on a fundamental maxim: “Investigate, verify and report.” These three actions form the backbone of responsible, credible and fact-based journalism. Beyond them, however, details and motives have particular importance in constructing every report, crime story or news analysis.

I am convinced that detail is the soul of every report, because it is precisely through detail that an event acquires meaning, context and a full informational dimension. A crime story without verified details risks remaining superficial, while reporting that fails to identify and analyze possible motives, where the facts and circumstances allow, often fails to explain the essence of the event to the public.

Journalists must go beyond what is visible on the surface, unravel the circumstances, compare testimony, analyze documents and seek answers to the essential questions: what happened, how did it happen, why did it happen and what circumstances preceded the event?

Of course, a motive must not be presented as fact unless it has been confirmed by testimony, documents or competent authorities. Detail builds the story, verification guarantees its credibility, and analysis of motives gives it professional depth. This is the kind of journalism I defend and promote: not the quick reporting of an event, but the unravelling of it through facts, accuracy and responsibility to the public.

Musa Sabedini is a journalist and lecturer at UBT, and the author of the book “The Media, Ethics, Reporting on Sensitive Situations, Investigations and Legal Concepts in Journalism,” published in 2023

Related