The struggle for liberation from oppressive regimes is never a clean business. In France, immediately after the end of the Second World War, more than 9,000 people were executed during the épuration sauvage, a violent purge by the Resistance Movement of suspected collaborators, which involved extrajudicial killings, torture, public humiliation, as well as the shaving of […]
Beware of friends who bring international tribunals

The struggle for liberation from oppressive regimes is never a clean business.
In France, immediately after the end of the Second World War, more than 9,000 people were executed during the épuration sauvage, a violent purge by the Resistance Movement of suspected collaborators, which involved extrajudicial killings, torture, public humiliation, as well as the shaving of women's heads, who were then paraded through the streets in “marches of shame” for their role in so-called collaboration horizontale – sex with Germans. Historians have documented many cases driven by rumors, personal vendettas, local rivalries, theft, or banal political score-settling.
In more modern times, Nelson Mandela's African National Congress, one of the most celebrated — and admired — liberation movements in the contemporary history of the world, was found to have committed serious human rights violations during the struggle against apartheid, including torture, arbitrary detention, and the execution of suspected collaborators and dissidents. South Africa's own Truth and Reconciliation Commission found that the ANC's military wing's security structures routinely used torture in its exile camps between 1979 and 1989, and that many detainees were sentenced to death and executed without adequate legal process.
East Timor's FRETILIN and its armed wing FALINTIL, another globally respected liberation movement that fought against a brutal occupation, were likewise found by the country's own Truth and Reconciliation Commission to have committed serious violations of the laws of war. These included torture, unlawful detention, the killing of civilians, even massacres, of entire villages accused of collaborating with Indonesian forces, as well as the execution of political and internal opponents.
Nevertheless, the judicial and reconciliation bodies established after liberation, both in South Africa and East Timor, took care to emphasize that these abuses, serious as they were, accounted for only a tiny fraction of the violations committed during the years of oppression and occupation by the white minority regime in South Africa and, respectively, by the Indonesian military.
Both Nelson Mandela, whose ANC also used violence to liberate the country from the apartheid machinery, and José Ramos-Horta, a senior leader and international spokesperson for East Timor's guerrilla movement, later won the Nobel Peace Prize in recognition of the outcomes of their long and brutal journeys to freedom. Even Yasser Arafat, who led a movement that had used brutal terrorism and killed entirely innocent people, including women and children, received the Nobel Peace Prize.
Hashim Thaçi, the political leader of Kosovo's liberation movement, was also co-nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize, initially by the Republican and Democratic co-chairs of the caucuses in the U.S. Congress, as well as by the Socialists and Democrats group in the European Parliament, for his role in postwar reconciliation efforts with Serbia.
Joe Biden, then Vice President of the United States, even called Thaçi “the George Washington of Kosovo” in 2010, for his role both in Kosovo's liberation and in building one of the most dynamic democracies in this troubled part of Europe. Former NATO Secretary General Lord Robertson called Thaçi “an extraordinary leader”, while the late and much-loved Secretary Madeleine Albright once wrote that she “believed in Thaçi's vision — a vision Kosovo had lacked”.
But decades after former President Bill Clinton expressed “admiration for the leadership” of Hashim Thaçi during the chaotic months after the war in Kosovo, our liberation movement would suffer one of the heaviest blows to its reputation from a hybrid court, formally established by Kosovo but based in The Hague and made up entirely of international judges and prosecutors.
I will not revisit the history of this court: the blackmail under which Kosovo was placed to establish it on the basis of an absurd organ-trafficking report, drawn up by a Swiss senator with a long history of positions against Kosovo's independence, following a request in the Council of Europe led by Konstantin Kosachev, a Russian deputy who is now under European Union sanctions. Equally well known is the dubious decision by Special Prosecutor Jack Smith to announce the indictment at a time when Thaçi was on an Austrian Airlines plane, traveling to Washington to meet President Trump at the White House for a peace agreement with Serbia.
But yesterday this court handed down heavy sentences against the KLA's political leader and former President of Kosovo, Hashim Thaçi, as well as three co-defendants, Kadri Veseli, Jakup Krasniqi, and Rexhep Selimi, all of whom played key roles in Kosovo's liberation and in leading the democratic institutions built after the war.
Most Kosovars were shocked not only by the severity of the first-instance sentences, which were harsher than those handed down to Serbian leaders and generals in the ICTY's Milutinović et al. case for crimes against humanity during the war in Kosovo, but even more by the narrative articulated by the presiding judge on which the verdict was based.
The international judges completely disregarded the substance of the testimony of former NATO Supreme Allied Commander Wesley Clark, as well as that of very senior American, British, and UN diplomats, who described Thaçi as a political, not a military, leader, and the KLA as a fragmented guerrilla movement with limited central control.
Nevertheless, the Trial Panel found that the defendants (and many other KLA commanders expressly named) were part of a “joint criminal enterprise” with a “common criminal purpose” to target the KLA's perceived opponents, while acquitting them of crimes against humanity.
Immediately after the shocking verdicts, many friendly embassies emphasized that the Trial Panel President had “stressed that the trial was not about the legitimacy of the Kosovo Liberation Army and its aim of an independent Kosovo, but about the use of certain criminal means by some of its members to achieve these aims”.
But this, of course, is not entirely true. The Trial Panel President did say this. But that clarification sat uneasily alongside the lengthy narrative that followed. His lengthy opening statement was filled with accusations, conclusions, and insinuations that called into question the very decision of these men, most of whom were then in their early or mid-twenties, to use violence in order to free themselves from an oppressive regime. The judge did not use his time before the world's media (nor, apparently, his confidential judgment of nearly 2,000 pages) to give a clear and indisputable explanation of the legality of armed resistance against an apartheid-like regime. Nor did he spend much time explaining that these abuses, serious as they were, represented only a small part of the violations committed over many years by Milošević's regime.
Foreign diplomats also point out that the judgments are not final. It is true that the convicted founding fathers of the Republic of Kosovo will appeal, but they will do so in light of the extraordinarily asymmetrical record of appeals filed by the Prosecution and the Defence. As experienced but deeply frustrated Thaçi lawyer Luka Mišetić noted in July, the Prosecution had filed three appeals and won all three, a 100 percent success rate. The Defence, meanwhile, had filed 44 appeals and lost all 44 — a 100 percent failure rate. The relationship between the Chambers and the Prosecution has become legally incestuous. There is no longer any meaningful separation or institutional distance, as even the Human Rights Committee of the Bar of England and Wales has pointed out — hardly an institution of KLA sympathizers.
As for reactions in Kosovo… Global music icons such as Dua Lipa and Rita Ora, football stars such as Granit Xhaka, and hundreds of thousands of others filled their platforms with KLA logos, accompanied by statements such as “Not in my name” and “Freedom has a name”, a clear backlash against the absurdity of judges who, ruling “in the name of the people of Kosovo”, declared the liberation movement of that people criminal. As for the political consequences, we will discuss those later.
Whatever happens on appeal, that finding has caused deep damage not only to the reputation of the four men, but also to the historical image of Kosovo's entire liberation movement. Daniel Serwer, a senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins SAIS Foreign Policy Institute and former senior U.S. diplomat, was highly critical of the verdict: “Americans and Europeans should be ashamed,” he wrote, arguing that they had “criminalized a liberation movement they themselves had supported and reduced international justice to political revenge”.
The broader irony is hard to ignore.
At a time when Western governments constantly talk about confronting hostile influence, historical revisionism, and Russia's hybrid warfare, they have now spent hundreds of millions of dollars to build and sustain an institution whose verdict offers exactly the kind of narrative ammunition their adversaries have sought for decades. For revisionists in Moscow and Belgrade, there was reason to uncork the champagne.
For liberation movements fighting for freedom and democracy around the world, the lesson will be clear: Beware of friends who bring international tribunals.

















