The vocabulary, definitions, and distinctions being bandied about today regarding democracy are endless. The ordinary Flamingos protester uses it, the Rama administration uses it, politicians use it all the time, the prime minister himself and Mr. Berisha and their entire entourages use it. But when you remember that democracy was also commonly talked about under socialism, you pause for a moment. The word Democracy was once often used by the communist leader Enver Hoxha himself.
Our Democracy Without Hardware and Software?!

The vocabulary, definitions, and distinctions being bandied about today regarding democracy are endless. The ordinary Flamingos protester uses it, the Rama administration uses it, politicians use it all the time, the prime minister himself and Mr. Berisha and their entire entourages use it. But when you remember that democracy was also commonly talked about under socialism, you pause for a moment. The word Democracy was once often used by the communist leader Enver Hoxha himself.
In any case, in the period after the Second World War (WWII), when a breeze of peace began to blow after the global catastrophe, thanks in part to various schools of political studies, perceptions and interpretations of democracy as a system of government multiplied greatly. Today, there is such inflation around this word that many systems of government that have nothing to do with democracy label themselves democratic. In our country’s case, the “Flamingos Protest” has now put it forward as an alternative within the slogan of “New Albania,” where people believe that it is enough for Rama, who has governed for four terms (by now almost personalizing the state through his power), to leave, and for him and Berisha to be put in prison, and things will change. Albania can truly become democratic!! “We want Albania like all of Europe” was the slogan of the 1990s, but it was first forgotten by those who uttered it most. Today’s naivety is more reminiscent of that of the first years after WWII or of the first months at the transition from Socialism to the Liberal Economy. It was a time when everyone believed. There were laws, there were states with separation of powers, and there were administrations with objectives.
Still, the best explanations of democracy are coming from our realities. And it is truly interesting how political scientists have also brought the very concept of democracy into the realm of cybernetics. In their seminal 1998 work in the field of political science, the well-known trio of political scientists (Richard Rose, William Mishler, and Christian Haerpfer), who were deeply interested in democracy in former communist countries, formulated a vocabulary and framework suited to the times. This meant that political institutions and procedures make up the “hardware” (the physical/technical part) of a democratic system, while public opinion, civic culture, and the rule of law serve as “software” (the program/operating system), what sustains and develops its operation. When a country adopts democratic laws (“software”) but lacks stable state infrastructure or courts to support them (“hardware”), the system develops glitches until it produces consequences. In their important 1998 book, “Democracy and Its Alternatives: Understanding Post-Communist Societies,” they explained their idea with evidence, but did more than that: they simplified the chaotic aspect that plagues us in Albania every day—the lack of institutions and people’s preparedness.
Albania is full of good laws, but they are almost impossible to implement by an incompetent and wholly unsympathetic administration. The consequences are connected to property and, especially, the unreformed justice system itself, which has now brought the backlog at the Court of Appeal of General Jurisdiction alone to the alarming figure of around 48,000 to 50,000 pending cases. The average waiting time for a civil case in this court exceeds 7 years, according to an analysis by the Institute for Public and Legal Studies.
In our argument, Albania has this corruption and political problem because trust in institutions, justice, and property ownership have never all existed simultaneously in their modern form. “Let us catch up on lost time,” wrote the physician Ylli Popa at the end of communism; he would go on to become president of the Academy of Sciences, but we never catch up. Worse still, when communism fell, we destroyed even the weak version of this triad that we had. Throughout history, Albanians have experienced institutions as being tied solely to political power. During the Ottoman period, trust was linked only to the head of the Turkish administrative unit (Pasha, spahi, etc.) in the locality; in Zog’s time, everything was tied to the king’s entourage and the clans close to him. Enver Hoxha took this to the extreme, placing the political institution of the Party of Labour of Albania above the state. This meant that after the 1990s, Albanians identified a strong state only with Berisha’s power (as he is showing even in recent days), whom they turned to for everything; with Rama today (with his immense power and almost total identification with the state); and with Nano, who governed for a short time, but in whose liberalization one could also see these elements in one form or another. Meanwhile, the administration, at least the part that deals directly with people, should have been detached, professional, and neutral, but it submitted to power and narrow interests rather than serving the public. It is still like that today, which is why Rama could not bypass it.
As for Justice, communism destroyed it here with the merciless Class War, while the Justice system, which had also abolished the legal profession, had only the Legal Codes and “support from the Party’s Teachings” as its compass—something it manifested even in the slogans inside the courtroom. And that is not all. After ’90: We did not carry out proper lustration, and some MPs in successive legislatures have reported that their colleagues were informants, while parties still do not vet their candidates. As for property, it is accompanied by endless paradoxes, with one side saying “return it to the former owner” and then the other side producing “the legalization lists” (for those who built without permits). It is claimed that a third of the cases against Albania at the Strasbourg Court concern property! More than in any other country in Europe. And when you cannot guarantee property, you cannot guarantee the institution either, since the institution’s primary duty is to guarantee and safeguard the sanctity of property. And when property is routinely not acquired or is insecure, you need a strongman, a friend, and especially a party.
Therefore, the Albanian of Flamingos and the other one sitting in a café these days face a long road ahead, as resolving these issues and tackling corruption will take decades. Of course, that is if the 21st-century Albanian were to wake up and understand how difficult it is and how much work will be needed for a modern Albania. At the very least, we owe Albanians the truth: we live in a wholly abnormal country. Albanian software and hardware over these 35 years show us that we have a long road ahead, because there is still no repair shop for this problem. Beyond the exhausting daily, monthly, yearly marathon…, we still have a long way to go because our Democracy has no hardware or software, and will probably remain without them (Homo Albanicus)

















