Writers usually keep a saying in reserve when they are asked about the state of the world and the nightmarish paradoxes surrounding us. In an interview with the late Greek journalist Anteos Hrisostomidis, the writer Daniel Kehlmann (also translated into Albanian by A. Kove) cited a saying by Dürrenmatt (whose work was translated by the late A. Klosi): a story does not end until it has found its worst possible version […]
Even the End Has a Smell…

Writers usually keep a saying in reserve when they are asked about the state of the world and the nightmarish paradoxes surrounding us. In an interview with the late Greek journalist Anteos Hrisostomidis, the writer Daniel Kehlmann (also translated into Albanian by A. Kove) cited a saying by Dürrenmatt (whose work was translated by the late A. Klosi): a story does not end until it has found its worst possible version. This suddenly came to mind when, a few days ago, at a panel at the SINTRAK festival (its first edition, curated and conceived by translator and author Milena Selimi), I asked the well-known Bulgarian writer and philosopher Todor P. Todorov about the times we are living in and how he perceived them ontologically.
There was a pause, then he carefully turned toward the audience at the “Puppet Theatre” and said something that shook you: “You have to hit rock bottom in order to change,” he repeated, something I had heard and read before. He fell silent to gauge the audience’s reaction. Then, looking at them, he added a rhetorical question: “But what, I wonder, is rock bottom?”
He himself answered after a few seconds that seemed like hours. “I was speaking on a topic in Russia. I repeated this idea and tried to elaborate on it, believing I had grasped the idea I was expressing about how I conceived of rock bottom philosophically. At the end of the event, an old woman came up to me and said: ‘Son, do you know what rock bottom is? What kind of end did you really mean? Have you experienced war? Famine? Extreme survival? Of course not,’ the old woman went on, ‘because if you had lived through them, you would understand that destitution, death and the end you perceive philosophically eventually become matter. It seems to be right there in front of you, and it has a stench whose name you can never quite find, because it is horrifying. I hope you never experience this smell, because you will be terrified… you will all be terrified.’”
We have made this rather long introduction to reflect on the moment Albania is going through, one for which there is no longer any comparison with another event in its history, which has been full of dark days. In the first quarter of the 21st century, no one has an answer to why democratic Albania is so disappointing. There are no explanations. There is not even a rationale that can explain the evil, the refusal to take responsibility, the gargantuan insatiability, the greed, the way institutions are exploited by people whose meritocratic credentials are in doubt, and so on. The dilemma deepens because the crisis Albania is going through exceeds our sensory capacities and our ability to think, apart from the irony directed at moral categories that no longer count. Not simply because of the latest scandal involving the head of SHISH, Vlora Hyseni, and the arrested businessman Agasi (if the leaked investigation material is genuine); not because of this parliament, whose intellectual and moral capacities are ever lower; or the empty propaganda and artificiality; or the futility; state corruption and the luxury that today form part of a cynicism shown on screens and hurled harshly and coldly in our faces.
And not because we are ignorant and do not understand, but because our very Being has now become chaotic, and seems like the tale of something absurd that we experience as “normal.” If we believe Heidegger (this is in the literature), the problem is ontological: Being today has withdrawn; it has weakened. Today’s Albanian crisis does not stem from a lack of knowledge; it is a clash between two ways of being that cannot find common ground. The first is the destiny of believing in the institution, which disappoints it; the second is linked to what it believes things should really be. If you carefully follow the reasoning put forward in forums by some of the people inspiring the Flamingo Revolution, you understand that the Albanian people have an extraordinary desire for change and deserve it. It feels as if we have suddenly returned to the distant 1930s, when Albanian intellectuals believed that change lay with the young and the ideas they were to pass on.
Today’s crisis, the endless cases of corruption (incinerators, 5D, reconstruction funds, AKSH and many, many others), the wiretaps (the author believes it is excessive for them to be selectively carried out and given to the public in this form), and the often useless work of the administration show that things have exceeded our capacity. Many colleagues, who claim to have access to numerous sources (this too is one of the peculiarities of our democracy), are convinced that even bigger scandals will follow. This is unsettling. When knowledge fails to provide direction, it is a sign that it is not your knowledge that is failing; it is your Being that is revealing itself as weak. Today, we are weaker, even though we perceive and react. Democracy is stronger because we protest and make demands, even if very little changes. Tirana and Pristina are protesting, but things remain as they are and look even bleaker.
What we have called “democracy” in Tirana for 36 years confirms two ideas. The first is what we are often told: democracy is a procedure. Elections are held, parties function (!), and EU reports appear to be respected and genuinely reflect the country’s development. The second is democracy as meaning: the idea that these procedures would make us part of the West and protect us from the cynicism of the history we are living through. In fact, we face a paradox: in Albania, 97% of Albanians consider corruption a very serious problem in the country (IRI); 80% of Albanians see the abuse of political power as the main factor behind this situation (IDM); 59% of citizens say they are dissatisfied with the way democracy is developing and functioning in Albania (IRI). This, then, is the weak democracy we are living through now. Institutions exist, but we do not understand their effectiveness. Are they ours? Have they been captured? Why is there no sense that change is coming?
All of this is more dangerous than a bitter end, because an end can also be replaced. But our democracy seems to be reaching a kind of end, one in which people stop feeling that they own it, even symbolically. In today’s state, where Rama is everything, he no longer needs to stop talking—and in fact he does not (the protest is putting this to the test)—but he has made Albanians feel that talking changes nothing. Criminals make the laws, and time is showing that they are untouchable; building permits go to the powerful, often outside the rules; your degree is of no use; MPs are often successful businessmen… and Albania is being abandoned. Relentlessly. Philosophically, this is the end of ontological ownership, the Bulgarian professor at the “Puppet Theatre,” once the first Albanian parliament, would have explained that day. Perhaps we have not yet felt this end, but its smell is so strong, and it seems to be brought on by the changes happening everywhere in Europe and by the gusts of news about the war that are coming ever more frequently. The Russian old woman knew this lesson from life, but her lessons “are of no use to anyone anymore.” We are destroying the beautiful democratic dream ourselves. Unfortunately, not only us Albanians, but everywhere. The smell of the end, the stench, apparently waits to reveal itself to us sooner or later… Only it will be too late. (Homo Albanicus)

















