Ekonomia Online
LATEST

The Specialist Chambers vs. Kosovo’s Independence

The Specialist Chambers vs. Kosovo’s Independence

That the approach of the Specialist Chambers has been, to put it mildly, strange in relation to the independence of the state that established them has also been noted in other indictments and judgments. It is also evident that they have not addressed at all the context in which the events unfolded (the war as a reaction to the Serbian state’s terror against the civilian population and the denial of Albanians’ fundamental political rights), and that those events have not been taken into account, not even as a mitigating circumstance.

That the approach of the Specialist Chambers has been, to put it mildly, strange in relation to the independence of the state that established them has also been noted in other indictments and judgments. It is also evident that they have not addressed at all the context in which the events unfolded (the war as a reaction to the Serbian state’s terror against the civilian population and the denial of Albanians’ fundamental political rights), and that those events have not been taken into account, not even as a mitigating circumstance.

But the height of it is found in this paragraph of the summary of the judgment dated September 16: “The Trial Panel found that the four accused and other persons in the KLA leadership, including those alleged to be members of the Joint Criminal Enterprise, had two objectives: Kosovo’s independence and the establishment of political and institutional control over what they hoped would be an independent Kosovo. These objectives were intended to be achieved by military, political and other means. The Trial Panel did not consider it necessary to determine whether these two objectives were, in themselves, criminal or unlawful.”

The very language, seemingly innocent but fundamentally neutral in relation to independence, from a “court” of Kosovo makes it entirely sui generis in domestic and international criminal law and humanitarian law.

Why should a court of Kosovo address whether it considered it necessary or unnecessary to determine whether the objective of independence was lawful or criminal? Is it not clear that independence is lawful, given that the Assembly of Kosovo itself established the court? What about the International Court of Justice ruling on the legality of the declaration of independence? What about NATO’s intervention?

It is clear that by relativizing the legality and objective of independence, the court aims to criminalize the activity of the four accused, portraying them as people who, outside any context, organized themselves into a joint criminal enterprise to exercise political control by any means.

Political control in Kosovo, occupied and devastated by Serbia. And yet this court has never characterized Serbia as an occupying power.

And how can we describe this court as just, as a defender of victims, when it fails the main test: by not treating Serbia as an occupying power and Kosovo’s independence as lawful.

Thus, this court becomes a purely political court, striking at the very foundations of the liberation war and seeking indirectly to tarnish its product as well: independence.

Related