Ekonomia Online
LATEST

There Are No Pure Cultures

There Are No Pure Cultures

In the 1990s, an entire generation was deprived of historical consciousness by a powerful and seemingly unprecedented narrative. This story, created as the Cold War was ending, declared that borders—real or imagined—had ceased to function as they once had. People were no longer confined […]

In the 1990s, an entire generation was deprived of historical consciousness by a powerful and seemingly unprecedented narrative. This story, created as the Cold War was ending, declared that borders—real or imagined—had ceased to function as they once had. People were no longer confined within their old geographies or identities. They now inhabited a new world that seemed to have broken away from the ordinary development of human society.

“Globalization” was the chosen concept for describing this transformative moment in human history. It described how new technologies and networks of connectivity had suddenly brought human communities closer together and made them permeable to an uncontrollable flow of people, ideas, goods, and cultural practices, moving freely through the integrated markets of the world economy. In the wake of this transformation, new terms emerged to express a new anxiety: the world had indeed become the “global village” Marshall McLuhan had predicted in the 1960s, but a world shaped by multinational corporations and “elite globalists” speaking a hegemonic “global English,” and leading a destructive “homogenization” (or “McDonaldization”) of human cultures that national borders were too weak to stop.

Over the past three decades, more and more people have begun to see our “global” world as a curse. With the compression of time and space, globalization seems to have disconnected us from the logic and flow of history. Our dubious, bastard identities—stitched together from scraps of different cultures—seem incompatible with the “authentic” traditions and ways of life of our ancestors. We have become strangers to the places they called home, to how they dressed, what they ate, and how they communicated with one another. And, without a model for how to live and without experience to learn from, the deafening siren calls of anti-globalization movements are drawing us ever more toward the safer identities and borders of a golden, lost past.

This narrative about globalization is the most successful scare story of our time. And, like all frightening tales, it feeds our fear of the great unknown.

But it is all an illusion. There is no new global world.

Our present seems this way only because we have forgotten our shared past. Globalization did not begin in the 1990s, nor in the last millennium. Remembering this old, shared history is a path toward another story, one that begins much, much earlier—long before the arrival of international supply chains, ships sailing the oceans, and the great Silk Roads crossing the continents. The story of globalization is written throughout human history. So why do we continue to tell this story incorrectly?

A stroll through the Grote Markt market, in the Dutch city of Groningen, sometime in the 2020s. A woman running a stall asks a customer if he wants the hummus “natural,” by which she means “plain.” He looks confused as she gestures toward the orange, green, and purple varieties of hummus she has on offer. It had taken him some time to try the original version—that pale paste that had prompted him to consume more chickpeas, sesame seeds, and olive oil than all his ancestors combined—so the purple hummus would have to wait for another day. He muttered, “The real thing, please,” and hurried to another stall to pick up the last item on his shopping list: potatoes, the most basic ingredient in Dutch cuisine. Elsewhere in the market, other customers were looking for their favorite ingredients. Some were seeking whole wheat flour for a French-style sourdough loaf or basmati rice for an Iraqi recipe; others bought cornmeal for a Nigerian pudding, tomatoes for a fresh Italian pasta sauce, or olives for a Greek salad.

Markets like this are perfect places to observe the movement and mixing of people, goods, ideas, and customs—what we call globalization today. They are also places where we can begin to imagine the longer history of this process.

Many historic markets were founded long before our global age. When the Grote Markt began operating in the late Middle Ages, few of the products now available to Groningen’s international community would have been present. At that time, market visitors also came from closer, more limited territories, and most of them still spoke their regional dialects. But in 1493, the imaginative horizons of everyday life in this and other European markets suddenly expanded, as news began to circulate of an extraordinary discovery: an unknown human world existed beyond Europe’s shores. It was a world so unexpected and so apparently different that it shook European consciousness to its foundations.

After Christopher Columbus arrived in 1492 in the lands that would later be called the “Americas,” humanity experienced a four-hundred-year process of intensive global integration, driven by imperialism, trade, religion, a new culture of movement, and an intellectual curiosity freed from the chains of tradition. As secure networks of maritime and land connections were established, the peoples of the “Old World” and the “New World” were brought together in the most violent and transformative way possible. This process opened the way for what the historian Alfred W. Crosby Jr. called in 1972 the “Columbian Exchange”: a vast, human-driven, intercontinental movement of animals, plants, and disease-carrying microorganisms—an exchange that forever changed Earth’s biological profile and the economic, cultural, and political lives of its inhabitants.

For many historians, this “early modern period,” spanning the 1500s to the 1800s, represents the first phase of globalization. In their view, this period gave birth to the first global capitalist economy and the first integrated world market, launched an unprecedented mixing of local cultures and ethnicities, and crystallized the first global consciousness of a shared world. It was so powerful that its effects are still felt today in diets, languages, economies, social and legal systems, international balances of political and military power, and scientific frameworks and institutions. This era even helped shape our philosophical concepts of the “self,” born of Europeans’ shock at discovering the “other.”

But even this era was not the first global age in human history. It was itself the product of earlier global movements, encounters, and exchanges. In fact, early modern globalization was simply an accelerated episode in a general process that has been present for tens of thousands of years.

Human collective memory is a partial and imperfect repository of our encounters with one another over time. We are not good at remembering, much less at acknowledging the ways these encounters have shaped our societies, cultures, and economies today. So how did we forget?

Globalization theorists who follow sociologist Roland Robertson use the term “glocalization” to describe how local cultures absorb products from the global market and transform them into something that seems new. Through this process, goods that come from elsewhere—technologies, ideas, symbols, artistic styles, social practices, or institutions—are assimilated, becoming hybrid recreations that take on new meanings. These recreations are then reused as new markers of cultural or class difference, embedding borrowed cultural products in the collective consciousness to the point that we no longer recognize them as foreign. And so the global becomes local, the foreign becomes familiar, and the “other” becomes “us.” Glocalization is the way and the reason we collectively forget. This is the quiet deception of every globalization in our history: our forgetting is its method and its seal of success.

Each generation inherits the legacies of global exchanges and reshapes them as its own. Digging through the sediments our ancestors have left in the collective consciousness is not something we do naturally. It is an act of remembrance and self-knowledge that can unsettle our identities, because it runs counter to the processes that give them their “authenticity.”

This excavation is made even more difficult by our tendency to focus on what is unique about the present. By limiting ourselves to the details of the current global moment, we overlook the most obvious manifestations of globalization’s deep past. Consider these broad, defining features of human civilization: some of our world religions, the dominant paradigm of written communication, and the ethical norms of social behavior that are widely shared. Also consider the (quasi-)universal way of agrarian life and our food and psychotropic order, which relies on an extraordinarily small number of starch crops (such as wheat, corn, and rice), domesticated animals (cows, chickens), and stimulants (coffee, sugar), consumed in much the same way across the planet. These characteristics predate our “global” age by thousands of years. And it can rightly be said that they are more fundamental features of human culture and more representative illustrations of globalization than K-pop [South Korean pop music] or German sandals [Birkenstocks]—which themselves are a late revival of identical or similar products that have circulated for at least 10,000 years.

Related